How to Have Difficult Conversations: A Guide for Leaders at Every Level
Holding difficult conversations with employees is an essential part of effective leadership. Whether addressing performance, behavior, expectations or accountability, these conversations help employees understand what is needed, where they stand and how they can move forward. Avoiding them can create confusion, frustration and missed opportunities for growth.
To have a difficult conversation well, check the facts first, decide on the one message that matters most, open with a clear and respectful statement of purpose, listen before responding and close with an agreement on next steps. The need does not stop at new managers. A global client recently told us that holding difficult conversations, delivering difficult messages and giving difficult feedback still show up as development needs from the senior leader team on down. The need can be sharper where change is constant and responsibilities cross functions. PPS International Limited builds this skill as part of our communication training for leaders.
This article covers why leaders avoid difficult conversations, how to prepare for and start one, how to handle the reactions that follow and what changes for senior leaders, with examples of difficult conversations at work. For talent development leaders, the section "For talent development leaders: building the skill from the senior team down" covers developing it across an organization.
In this video, we share a few key phrases and tips on how to begin a difficult conversation.
What makes a conversation difficult
A difficult conversation is one in which the person starting it expects the other person to be disappointed, upset or defensive about what they will hear. The stakes matter more than the topic: the same message about a missed deadline may be routine with one employee and difficult with another. In organizations, difficult conversations tend to fall into three groups:
- Delivering a difficult message. A decision, change or piece of bad news the other person did not want, such as a role change, a cancelled project or a declined request.
- Giving difficult feedback. Telling someone that their performance or behavior is not meeting the standard, including a high performer whose behavior is affecting others.
- Resolving an issue between people. A disagreement, a missed commitment between peers or a pattern that has continued too long, where both people have a view and an agreement is needed.
Why leaders avoid difficult conversations
Leaders at every level, including experienced ones, put off difficult conversations. The reasons we hear most often in our programs include:
- They do not like having them. Few people enjoy disappointing someone, and the discomfort starts well before the conversation does.
- They do not know how to start. Without a clear opening, the conversation feels riskier than it is, so it waits.
- They are afraid of the other person's reaction. Leaders worry about anger, tears or arguments and about whether they can handle those reactions in the moment.
- They wonder if they are overreacting. A leader may question whether the issue is real, or whether they are the only one seeing it.
The fear of the reaction is often larger than the reaction itself. A classic 2018 set of experiments on honest communication found that people who shared negative feedback expected the other person to react more negatively than that person reported, and expected more harm to the relationship than they experienced [1]. A 2022 study of nearly 2,000 participants, including more than 700 recently employed adults, found that people underestimate how much others want to receive constructive feedback; imagining themselves in the other person's position narrowed the gap [2].
Avoiding these conversations has a cost because they are not rare. In a 2024 SHRM survey of 1,971 U.S. workers, 39% of managers and supervisors said they have a difficult conversation with their direct reports at least weekly [3]. When a conversation waits, the issue often continues, others notice and the eventual conversation carries more history.
How to prepare for a difficult conversation
A short amount of preparation reduces the chance of a difficult conversation going off course. Here is how we suggest leaders prepare:
- Check the facts and your own reaction. Identify what you observed, how often it happened and its impact on the work, the team or customers. If you wonder whether you are overreacting, consider whether this is a pattern or a single event and whether it relates to a standard the person knows. When the answers are unclear, gather more information first.
- Decide on the one message that matters most. Keep things as simple as you can and focus on one key message or problem to be solved. If there are several issues, choose the one with the greatest impact on the work.
- Determine the outcome you want. Identify the agreement or change that would make the conversation a success, and what you are willing to be flexible about.
- Plan the opening and the reason behind the message. Prepare the first two sentences and the explanation. A review of 54 samples found that explaining the reason for an unfavorable decision improved how fair people judged it and their willingness to cooperate [4].
- Anticipate the reaction. Consider how the person may respond and how their behavioral preferences may shape that response, then plan how you will listen if the reaction is strong.
- Choose the time and place. Hold the conversation privately, soon after the event and with enough time. For a sensitive topic, meet in person or on video.
Some nervousness before the conversation is useful. In three studies, managers who felt more self-assured delivered bad news less respectfully, while some anxiety helped them treat the other person fairly [5]. Our Delivering Difficult News quick reference guide is a planning tool for these conversations. When the conversation is about performance, our guide on how to handle employee performance issues helps leaders diagnose the cause first.
How to start a difficult conversation
The way a difficult conversation begins matters. The opening sets the tone, creates clarity and helps determine whether the employee feels attacked, surprised or invited into a productive discussion. A strong opening should be direct, respectful and grounded in the purpose of the conversation. When leaders begin a difficult conversation with clarity and care, they increase the likelihood that the conversation will lead to understanding, ownership and meaningful change.
In the video, two key phrases do this work:
- "I have some information to share and discuss with you."
- "My goal for the conversation is to find a solution that works for both of us."
A short preface like these prepares the other person without delaying the message. The examples table later in this article includes an opening for six common situations. No matter how you start a conversation, keep in mind the video's three reminders:
- Be assertive in your communication. You want to maintain the relationship while also resolving any issues. Assertive communication balances the other person's needs with the need to get the work done, and our Assertive Communication program builds the skill.
- Use a positive tone of voice. People read tone even more than words.
- Keep things as simple as you can. Focus on one key message or problem to be solved.
How direct an opening should be varies across cultures. Directness can be interpreted as rudeness in some cultures, and indirectness can come across as agreement in others [6]. Leaders with global teams can adapt the preface while keeping the message itself clear. Our Having Tough Conversations program practices a message format leaders can use for any difficult conversation.
How to handle reactions and defensiveness
Even a well-planned opening can meet a strong reaction. Defensiveness is a common response to hearing something unwelcome, and leaders who expect it are less likely to be thrown by it.
Listening does the most to lower defensiveness. In four experiments, people who were listened to well during a disagreement reflected less defensively and softened their positions [7]. Reflective listening means summarizing what the person said, including the feeling behind it, before responding: "It sounds like you feel the deadline was never realistic. Tell me more about that."
Here is a process for handling expected and unexpected defensiveness:
- Pause and listen. Let the person finish, and avoid debating the first reaction.
- Acknowledge what you heard. Summarize the content and the feeling before responding.
- Restate the purpose. Return to the one message and the goal of finding a solution that works for both of you.
- Keep to observations and impact. Describe what happened and its effect, and avoid labels about character or intent.
- Agree on the next step, or a time to continue. If emotions are too high for a productive discussion, agree on a time to continue within a day or two so the issue is not dropped.
Here are reactions leaders often meet and what tends to help.
| Reaction | What It May Sound Like | What Helps |
|---|---|---|
| Anger | "This is unfair. You never said anything before." | Stay calm, acknowledge the frustration and restate the purpose and the specific observation |
| Distress or tears | Silence or visible upset | Pause, offer time and return to the message when the person is ready, later the same day if needed |
| Denial | "That is not what happened." | Share the specific observation and its source, then ask how they see it |
| Blame | "The other team never sends their data on time." | Acknowledge the factor, then return to what is within the person's control |
| Counterattack | "What about your own decisions?" | Offer to discuss it as a separate topic at another time, then return to the message |
| Quick agreement | "Fine, whatever you want." | Check commitment by agreeing on specific next steps and a follow-up date |
Some people react strongly every time they hear something unwelcome, and leaders may start to feel held hostage by the reaction. Acknowledge the reaction, hold to the message and continue the conversation later if needed. If the pattern continues, it becomes a behavior issue of its own. When an employee disagrees with the assessment itself, our article on helping employees have a realistic view of their performance covers that conversation, and our Managing Conflict program builds skill in resolving disagreements.
Being truthful is the compassionate choice
Many leaders delay difficult conversations because they want to be kind. Holding them takes courage and conviction, and a mindset that the individual, the team and the organization all benefit from the conversation. The individual gets the information they need to improve or decide, and the team and the organization stop working around an unresolved issue.
Leaders who see being truthful as compassionate, kind and authentic tend to find these conversations easier to start. The research on constructive feedback points the same way: people often want to hear it more than others assume [2]. Rasmus Hougaard and Jacqueline Carter make this case in Compassionate Leadership: How to Do Hard Things in a Human Way, which we summarize in our review of the book. Our Compassionate Leadership program builds the skill of being authentic and truthful about performance.
Credibility starts before the conversation
Effective leaders manage in such a way as to prevent as many performance problems as they can. They set expectations, provide ongoing feedback and communicate well. But they also don't shy away from delivering difficult messages or holding a difficult conversation with an employee when it's important to results.
A leader who only ever delivers bad news or difficult feedback may lose credibility when the next difficult message arrives. People tend to take difficult feedback more seriously from someone who also recognizes what goes well, gives feedback regularly and follows through. A 2026 review of 24 studies found that supervisor characteristics relate to how employees take in feedback, with the supervisor's credibility among the most studied and most strongly linked [8].
Regular positive and developmental feedback is less common than leaders may think. In May 2024, only 23% of U.S. employees strongly agreed they had received meaningful feedback in the past week [9]. People also underestimate how good a compliment makes the other person feel, and overestimate how awkward giving it will be [10]. Two habits build the history that makes difficult messages credible: the future-focused conversation in our feedforward discussion video and the five performance conversations top-performing managers have mastered.
Difficult conversations for senior leaders
Difficult conversations are often treated as a frontline leader skill, taught in new manager programs. In our work with global organizations, the need also shows up on the senior leader team. Four conditions make the conversations more frequent and more consequential at that level:
- The rate of change. Restructuring, new technology and shifting priorities mean more decisions that disappoint someone.
- The matrix. Senior leaders depend on peers in other functions and regions. They cannot work in silos, and a delayed conversation affects more than their own area of responsibility.
- A global audience. Expectations about directness differ across cultures, so the same message may need a different preface in different regions [6].
- Less candid feedback flowing upward. In SHRM's survey, senior leaders and executives were the group workers least often had difficult conversations with [3]. A 2026 study found that people gave more high-quality feedback the higher their status relative to the person asking, which suggests feedback flowing up to senior leaders may be thinner [11]. A classic study of U.S. CEOs found that flattery and agreement from others raised their overconfidence and reduced strategic change after poor performance [12].
Senior leaders can also fall into one of two extremes. Some avoid the conversation and let the issue travel through the matrix. Others deliver the message aggressively, and stories about it may travel even faster. Across 53 studies, destructive leadership was among the strongest predictors of poorer mental health in followers [13]. How senior leaders handle these conversations may also show everyone below them how it is done in the organization.
| Area | Frontline Leaders | Senior Leaders |
|---|---|---|
| Who is in the conversation | Direct reports and sometimes a peer | Peers across functions and regions, direct reports who lead teams of their own, boards and clients |
| What delay can cost | Frustration and lower performance in one team | Slower decisions and confusion across several areas of responsibility |
| Typical topics | Missed commitments, behavior, workload and ratings | Restructuring, priorities and resources, a peer's commitments and a leader's behavior |
| Common failure mode | Softening the message until it is lost, or avoiding it | Avoiding the conversation, or delivering it aggressively |
| What helps | A planning tool, practice and a clear opening | Executive coaching with an assessment of behavioral preferences, practice with real situations and candid feedback from peers |
For senior leaders, leadership and executive coaching is often a practical place to build the skill, because their conversations are specific to their role and organization.
Examples of difficult conversations at work
Here are examples of difficult conversations at work, with an opening for each and what to watch for.
| Situation | An Opening Line | What to Watch For |
|---|---|---|
| A team member has missed three deadlines in a month | "I would like to talk about the report deadlines this month. I have some information to share and discuss with you." | Whether the cause is skill, workload or something outside work |
| A high performer's behavior is affecting the team | "Your results this quarter have been strong. I also need to talk with you about how team meetings are going." | Defensiveness that points to results; keep to specific behaviors and their impact |
| A role or project change the person did not want | "I have news about the project that affects your role. I want to explain the reason and talk about what it means for you." | Questions you cannot answer yet; share what you know and when you will know more |
| A peer in another function keeps missing handoffs | "My goal for the conversation is to find a solution that works for both of us. The handoffs between our teams have slipped three times this quarter." | Escalating before the two of you have tried to agree on a fix |
| A senior leader disagrees with a peer's decision | "I think we see things from different points of view on this. I would like to understand how you see this before we decide anything." | A debate about positions; focus on the shared outcome for the organization |
| A leader needs to raise a concern with their own manager | "I have some information to share that will be helpful about the launch timeline, and I would like your view on it." | Timing and setting; choose a moment when your manager can give it attention |
For the last situation, our article on managing up covers conversations with your own manager.
For talent development leaders: building the skill from the senior team down
Talent development leaders often hear that difficult conversations are still a development need, even after years of training for new managers. Here are a few things to consider from the point of view of talent development.
Recognize and share the value to the organization
Through tailored development, leaders can benefit from the structure, language and practice they need to approach difficult conversations with greater confidence and skill. When leaders know how to prepare, open the conversation, listen, respond and agree on next steps, they are better equipped to address issues early and constructively. This has the potential to have a clear business impact, such as:
- Improving quality of work product and service.
- Reducing turnover and thereby avoiding costs associated with hiring replacements.
- Improving achievement of targets and increasing productivity levels.
- Reducing escalations and employee relations complaints.
As leaders become more confident in holding difficult conversations with employees, they are more likely to engage employees directly, reduce misunderstandings and create clearer expectations. Over time, this strengthens accountability, trust and performance across the team.
Look for cues that leaders need the skill
Cues you may notice include:
- Issues that managers could handle are passed to HR instead.
- Engagement survey items on feedback or clarity of expectations score low.
- Decisions that cross functions slow down while disagreements go unresolved.
- Teams avoid raising issues with a leader and work around them, or a few leaders are known for aggressive delivery.
Consider how to build the skill at scale, from the senior team down
Here are four ways we help organizations build skill in difficult conversations:
- Executive coaching with an assessment. An assessment of values and behavioral preferences shows each leader what makes these conversations easier or more difficult for them, and coaching applies that insight to the conversations they face. Our article on choosing leadership assessments covers the options.
- Culture work that builds candor into performance management. Make giving and receiving feedback part of performance management, from goal setting to reviews, so candor and openness are expected and supported. In SHRM's survey, workers who rated their workplace high on civility and psychological safety were nearly five times as likely to describe difficult conversations as productive [3]. Psychological safety also supports learning and performance when conditions are changing [14].
- Skill building for difficult behaviors and reactions. Practice with participants' own situations and feedback on that practice build confidence in handling tricky behaviors and reactions. In simulated layoff meetings, managers who completed bad news training delivered the news more fairly, and the people receiving it reacted less negatively [15]. Our Having Tough Conversations, Giving & Receiving Feedback and Compassionate Leadership programs focus on this practice.
- On-the-job tools. Planning tools and quick references, such as our Delivering Difficult News quick reference guide, help leaders prepare for and hold the conversation when it comes, often weeks after any training.
Be aware of how other organizations solve for it
An Americas OEM parts distributor built these skills across several hundred leaders at all levels of experience with a practical two-hour workshop, "Doing the Tough Stuff Well," described in our performance conversations article.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best opening for a difficult conversation?
The best opening for a difficult conversation is short, direct and respectful and states your purpose. "I have some information to share and discuss with you" and "My goal for the conversation is to find a solution that works for both of us" work in most situations. In some cultures a longer preface is expected.
What should you do if the other person gets defensive or angry?
If the other person gets defensive or angry, pause and listen, then summarize what you heard before responding. Restate the purpose of the conversation and keep to specific observations and their impact. If emotions stay high, agree on a time to continue within a day or two.
Should senior leaders be trained in difficult conversations?
Yes, senior leaders benefit from building skill in difficult conversations, often as much as new managers do. Their conversations affect several areas of responsibility at once, and they tend to receive less candid feedback. Executive coaching with an assessment of behavioral preferences, practice with real situations and feedback from peers suit this group.
How is a difficult conversation different from giving feedback?
A difficult conversation and giving feedback overlap. Feedback describes how someone's performance or behavior compares with a standard, and much of it is positive. A difficult conversation is any conversation the other person may not want to have, including difficult feedback, bad news, decisions and disagreements. Our Giving & Receiving Feedback program covers feedback itself.
Where to start
Watch the video, then choose one conversation you have been putting off and prepare it with the steps above (check the facts, decide on one message, determine the outcome, plan the opening, anticipate the reaction and choose the time and place). If you lead talent development, ask leaders at each level, including the senior team, which difficult conversations they put off most, and start there. We offer virtual and in-person training programs on holding difficult conversations, including Having Tough Conversations, Giving & Receiving Feedback and Compassionate Leadership, as well as leadership coaching and other resources for working well with others.
Contact us if your leaders put off the conversations that matter most and you want help building their confidence to hold them.
Talk to us about difficult conversations
References
- Levine, E. E. and Cohen, T. R. (2018). You can handle the truth: Mispredicting the consequences of honest communication. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 147(9), 1400–1429. doi:10.1037/xge0000488.
- Abi-Esber, N., Abel, J. E., Schroeder, J. and Gino, F. (2022). "Just letting you know…" Underestimating others' desire for constructive feedback. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 123(6), 1362–1385. doi:10.1037/pspi0000393.
- SHRM (2024). Difficult and Political Conversations in the Workplace. shrm.org.
- Shaw, J. C., Wild, E. and Colquitt, J. A. (2003). To justify or excuse? A meta-analytic review of the effects of explanations. Journal of Applied Psychology, 88(3), 444–458. doi:10.1037/0021-9010.88.3.444.
- Hillebrandt, A., Saldanha, M. F., Brady, D. L. and Barclay, L. J. (2022). Delivering bad news fairly: The influence of core self-evaluations and anxiety for the enactment of interpersonal justice. Human Relations, 75(7), 1238–1269. doi:10.1177/00187267211011000.
- Meyer, E. (2014). The Culture Map: Breaking Through the Invisible Boundaries of Global Business. PublicAffairs.
- Itzchakov, G., Weinstein, N., Leary, M., Saluk, D. and Amar, M. (2024). Listening to understand: The role of high-quality listening on speakers' attitude depolarization during disagreements. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 126(2), 213–239. doi:10.1037/pspa0000366.
- Zyberaj, J. (2026). Examining the relationship between supervisory feedback characteristics and employee feedback processing: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Current Psychology, 45(14). doi:10.1007/s12144-026-09323-y.
- Gallup (2024). U.S. Employee Engagement Inches Up Slightly After 11-Year Low. gallup.com.
- Zhao, X. and Epley, N. (2021). Insufficiently complimentary? Underestimating the positive impact of compliments creates a barrier to expressing them. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 121(2), 239–256. doi:10.1037/pspa0000277.
- Hu, X., Zhou, Y. and Zhu, H. (2026). To give or not to give? The influence of relative status and tie strength on feedback giving. Applied Psychology, 75(2). doi:10.1111/apps.70072.
- Park, S. H., Westphal, J. D. and Stern, I. (2011). Set up for a fall: The insidious effects of flattery and opinion conformity toward corporate leaders. Administrative Science Quarterly, 56(2), 257–302. doi:10.1177/0001839211429102.
- Montano, D., Schleu, J. E. and Hüffmeier, J. (2023). A meta-analysis of the relative contribution of leadership styles to followers' mental health. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 30(1), 90–107. doi:10.1177/15480518221114854.
- Edmondson, A. C. and Bransby, D. P. (2023). Psychological safety comes of age: Observed themes in an established literature. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 10, 55–78. doi:10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-120920-055217.
- Richter, M., König, C. J., Koppermann, C. and Schilling, M. (2016). Displaying fairness while delivering bad news: Testing the effectiveness of organizational bad news training in the layoff context. Journal of Applied Psychology, 101(6), 779–792. doi:10.1037/apl0000087.