---
title: Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scale (BARS) Examples | PPS International
description: A behaviorally anchored rating scale (BARS) describes what performance looks like at each level. See three examples and the steps to build your own.
image: https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-a6574d51550a99f37e46.jpg
---

[Skip to main content](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/behaviorally-anchored-rating-scale#main-content)

[![PPS International Limited](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/raw_assets/public/pps-international/assets/images/logo.svg)](https://www.ppsinternational.net/)

[Expertise](https://www.ppsinternational.net/expertise)

[Leadership Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/leadership-development) [Talent Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/talent-development) [Communication & Influence](https://www.ppsinternational.net/communication-influence) [Change & Transition](https://www.ppsinternational.net/change-transition) [Sales & HR Effectiveness](https://www.ppsinternational.net/sales-hr-effectiveness) [Performance Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/performance-support) [Implementation Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/implementation-support)

[Solutions](https://www.ppsinternational.net/solutions)

[Assessments](https://www.ppsinternational.net/assessments) [Contract Training & Facilitation](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contract-training-facilitation) [Coaching Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/coaching) [Instructional Design Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/instructional-design) [Interaction Styles](https://www.ppsinternational.net/interaction-styles) [Training Administration](https://www.ppsinternational.net/training-administration) [Training Programs](https://www.ppsinternational.net/programs)

[Shop](https://shop.ppsinternational.net/) [Resources](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources)

[About](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about)

[About PPS](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about) [Who We Serve](https://www.ppsinternational.net/who-we-serve)

[Get in touch](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contact)

Search the site

Search

Search the site

Search

Expertise

[Explore all expertise](https://www.ppsinternational.net/expertise) [Leadership Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/leadership-development) [Talent Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/talent-development) [Communication & Influence](https://www.ppsinternational.net/communication-influence) [Change & Transition](https://www.ppsinternational.net/change-transition) [Sales & HR Effectiveness](https://www.ppsinternational.net/sales-hr-effectiveness) [Performance Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/performance-support) [Implementation Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/implementation-support)

Solutions

[Explore all solutions](https://www.ppsinternational.net/solutions) [Assessments](https://www.ppsinternational.net/assessments) [Contract Training & Facilitation](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contract-training-facilitation) [Coaching Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/coaching) [Instructional Design Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/instructional-design) [Interaction Styles](https://www.ppsinternational.net/interaction-styles) [Training Administration](https://www.ppsinternational.net/training-administration) [Training Programs](https://www.ppsinternational.net/programs)

Explore

[Resources](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources) [About PPS](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about) [Who We Serve](https://www.ppsinternational.net/who-we-serve) [Shop](https://shop.ppsinternational.net/) [Get in touch](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contact)

Article [Sales & HR Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources?topic=sales-hr-development) November 16, 2026 By [Kelly Fairbairn](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about/kelly-fairbairn)

# Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scale (BARS): Examples and How to Build One

A behaviorally anchored rating scale (BARS) is a rating scale in which each level is described by an example of what a person does at that level of performance. Raters compare what they observed with those specific behaviors, so everyone works from the same reference point. Labels such as "poor" and "excellent" leave each rater to decide what the levels mean.

Behaviorally anchored rating scales appear wherever consistent judgments matter, from performance reviews to assessment centers and structured interviews. This article shows three examples, explains how to build a scale step by step and covers where BARS help, how to train raters and the limits worth knowing. It draws on research and on the assessment work we do at PPS International Limited, described on our [employee assessment tools](https://www.ppsinternational.net/assessments) page.

## What is a behaviorally anchored rating scale?

A behaviorally anchored rating scale is a numbered scale, often with five or seven points, in which some or all points carry a short description of observable behavior. Those descriptions are the behavioral anchors, and a scale built this way is often called a BARS rating scale. A rater reads the anchors and chooses the point that best matches what the person did.

The format comes from Patricia Smith and Lorne Kendall's classic 1963 study \[1\]. They built anchors from examples of behavior supplied by people who knew the work, then kept the examples that a second group placed consistently in the same dimension and at the same level. That second step, often called retranslation, is still the core of building a scale today. The British spelling, behaviourally anchored rating scale, refers to the same format.

A graphic rating scale asks raters to judge a quality, such as "communication," from low to high. A behaviorally anchored rating scale asks them to compare what they saw with descriptions of what someone does at each level. The behaviorally anchored version takes more work to build, and it gives raters and the people they rate the same picture of each level.

## Behaviorally anchored rating scale examples

Here are three examples. The first anchors all five points; the other two anchor the ends and the middle, which is often enough for everyday use.

### Example 1: Resolving a customer complaint (customer service role)

| Rating | Behavioral Anchor |
| --- | --- |
| 5: Highly effective | Acknowledges the customer's frustration and confirms the facts; resolves the issue on first contact or sets a follow-up time and later checks that the fix worked |
| 4: Effective | Listens without interrupting, explains the options clearly and resolves the issue or hands it off with all details documented |
| 3: Meets the standard | Follows the complaint process accurately and resolves routine issues; asks for help with unusual requests |
| 2: Partly effective | Resolves the issue only after repeated contact or escalation; explanations to the customer are incomplete |
| 1: Ineffective | Argues with the customer, blames other teams or closes the case without resolving the issue |

![Example of a behaviorally anchored rating scale drawn as a vertical scale for resolving a customer complaint. 5, highly effective: acknowledges frustration, resolves on first contact or follows up and checks the fix. 4, effective: listens, explains options and resolves or hands off with details documented. 3, meets the standard: follows the process and resolves routine issues. 2, partly effective: resolves only after repeated contact or escalation. 1, ineffective: argues, blames others or closes the case unresolved.](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hs-fs/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/behaviorally-anchored-rating-scale-example.png?width=1200&height=1000&name=behaviorally-anchored-rating-scale-example.png)

*Example 1 drawn as a vertical scale, the traditional layout for behaviorally anchored rating scales.*

### Example 2: Setting expectations with a direct report (manager)

| Rating | Behavioral Anchor |
| --- | --- |
| 5: Highly effective | Describes the outcome, the timing and why the work matters; offers guidance on methods and discusses what could get in the way; agrees on follow-up and checks that the employee understands |
| 3: Effective | Describes the outcome and the deadline and answers questions; follow-up is informal |
| 1: Rarely effective | Assigns work without explaining the outcome or the deadline; the employee learns the expectations when the work is reviewed |

The top anchor in this example follows the setting-expectations conversation in our article on [performance conversations](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/5-conversations-top-performing-managers-have-mastered).

### Example 3: Uncovering customer needs (sales representative)

| Rating | Behavioral Anchor |
| --- | --- |
| 5: Highly effective | Asks open questions about the customer's goals and constraints, confirms what they heard and connects later recommendations to the needs the customer described |
| 3: Effective | Asks a planned set of questions and records the answers; follow-up questions are limited |
| 1: Rarely effective | Presents products before asking about the customer's situation; questions focus on closing the sale |

## BARS vs other rating scales

Behaviorally anchored rating scales are one of several common formats. Here is how they compare:

| Format | How Levels Are Defined | Where It Fits | Watch-Outs |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Graphic rating scale | Numbers or adjectives, such as 1 to 5 or "poor" to "excellent" | Quick ratings where precision matters less, such as pulse surveys | Raters may read the same label differently; ratings can drift upward |
| Behaviorally anchored rating scale (BARS) | A description of observable behavior at some or all points | Assessments, interviews and reviews where consistent judgments matter | More effort to build; anchors may not match what a rater observed |
| Behavioral observation scale | How often the person shows each listed behavior, from "rarely" to "very often" | Development feedback and 360s that focus on how often behaviors occur | Long behavior lists can tire raters; frequency may not reflect quality |
| Narrative or critical incident notes | Written examples of effective and ineffective behavior, without a scale | Coaching conversations and documentation between reviews | Difficult to compare across people; quality depends on the writer |

Classic research found that behaviorally anchored scales did not consistently produce better results than simpler graphic scales \[2\]. Much of their value may come from the work behind them: dimensions defined with people who know the job, anchors drawn from real examples and raters trained to use them.

## How to build a behaviorally anchored rating scale

Here are the steps we recommend. Teams often move back and forth between them, especially between writing anchors and testing them.

1. **Choose the role and the dimensions.** Start from the competency model or the job's key responsibilities, and limit the scale to the few dimensions that matter most for the decision or the development goal. Our article on [competency development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/is-competency-development-still-important) covers building the model itself.
2. **Collect examples of effective and ineffective behavior.** Ask managers, strong performers and others who know the work to describe specific situations, what the person did and what happened as a result. These examples are often called critical incidents. Online surveys and collaborative tools make it easier to gather many of them; in one research project, managers supplied about 430 examples for a single set of scales \[3\].
3. **Write behavioral statements.** Turn each example into a short statement of observable behavior, leaving out adjectives such as "excellent" or "poor." Some teams use a company-approved Gen AI tool to group similar examples or suggest first drafts, with subject matter experts reviewing and editing every statement.
4. **Check that others place each statement the same way.** Ask a second group of experts to sort the statements into dimensions and rate the level each describes. Keep the statements with strong agreement and revise or drop the rest, as in the original retranslation method \[1\].
5. **Assign levels and choose the anchors.** Use the experts' ratings to place statements on the scale, then choose one or two clear anchors for each level that needs one. Anchoring the ends and the middle is often enough; anchoring every point can help where ratings carry high stakes.
6. **Pilot the scale and check agreement.** Ask several raters to score the same examples, such as recorded role plays or written cases, and compare their ratings. Where raters disagree, clarify the anchor or the rater instructions before the scale goes into use.
7. **Review the scale as roles change.** Revisit the anchors when the job, its tools or the strategy change, and retire anchors that no longer describe how the work is done.

## Where organizations use BARS

Behaviorally anchored rating scales can support most processes in which people judge performance or potential. A few common uses:

- **Performance reviews.** Anchors give managers and employees the same picture of each rating level and make the review conversation more specific. Our [*Conducting Performance Reviews*](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/programs/conducting-performance-reviews) program covers holding that conversation.
- **360 feedback.** Anchored items can make ratings from peers and direct reports more comparable. Because 360s measure perceptions, we recommend a debrief for each participant and keeping results out of employment-related decisions. Our guide to [choosing leadership assessment tools](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/choosing-the-right-leadership-assessments-for-your-priorities) covers when a 360 fits.
- **Self-assessments.** Anchors let people rate themselves against the same descriptions their manager uses, which makes differences in perception easier to discuss. Our article on [employee skills assessment](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/employee-skills-assessment) covers self-assessments, including two self-assessment scales PPS clients use.
- **Assessment centers.** Observed simulations are best reviewed by a limited number of trained assessors working against a tightly defined set of criteria. In a [sales assessment center](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/case-studies/sales-assessment-center-for-global-sales-professionals-a-case-study) PPS ran for a global sales force, we trained assessors within the client organization, and the observation checklists took cultural differences in behavior into account.
- **Structured interviews.** A structured interview asks every candidate the same questions and scores the answers against agreed criteria, and behaviorally anchored scales are a common way to define those criteria. A 2022 reanalysis of selection research ranked structured interviews first among the selection procedures it studied for predicting job performance \[4\]. Our [*Hiring the Best*](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/programs/hiring-the-best) program builds these interviewing skills.
- **Observation of facilitators and trainers.** Our [facilitator evaluation form](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/videos/video-how-pps-ensures-facilitator-quality) anchors the middle and the ends of its 1 to 5 scale, and observers recalibrate if most sessions come back scored 4s and 5s.
- **Skill demonstrations after training.** Anchored observation checklists help trainers and managers judge whether people apply a new skill on the job.

## How to train raters to use BARS consistently

Anchors alone do not guarantee agreement.

Rater training helps close that gap. Frame-of-reference training has raters practice on shared examples, compare their ratings with expert ratings and discuss the differences until they apply the anchors the same way. A 2024 analysis of four studies found this training most effective at helping raters identify low performance, with little difference across training settings, and it pointed to rater training as a key influence on the quality of ratings \[5\]. A few practices we recommend:

- **Practice on shared examples.** Use recorded role plays, written cases or work samples that every rater scores, then compare the ratings with the agreed answer.
- **Discuss the reasoning behind differences.** Ask raters which anchor they matched and why; disagreements often point to an anchor that needs clearer wording.
- **Calibrate before each cycle.** A short session before reviews or an assessment center helps raters reset to the same standard.
- **Watch for drift.** If most ratings cluster at the top of the scale, recalibrate the raters or revisit the anchors.

## Advantages and limitations of BARS

Advantages include:

- **A shared reference point.** Raters and the people they rate see the same description of each level.
- **Job-specific language.** Anchors written from real examples describe the work as it is done in the organization.
- **Feedback that is ready to use.** The anchor above someone's current level describes the next step in concrete terms.
- **Ratings that are easier to explain.** A rating tied to described behavior can be easier to explain and defend than a number alone.

Limitations include:

- **Time to build.** Collecting examples, sorting them and testing the scale takes time from managers and subject matter experts.
- **Anchors that miss what a rater saw.** A person may do things that match none of the anchors, which leaves raters to interpret.
- **Mixed evidence against simpler formats.** Classic research found BARS did not consistently produce better results than graphic scales \[2\].
- **Dependence on rater training.** Without training and calibration, agreement between raters can stay low \[5\].

## Common mistakes when building BARS

- **Writing anchors as traits.** Words such as "dependable" or "a strong communicator" leave each rater to decide what they mean. Describe what the person does instead.
- **Rating too many dimensions.** Long scales tire raters and blur distinctions, so focus on the few dimensions that matter most.
- **Copying generic anchors across roles.** Anchors borrowed from another job may not describe the work in this one.
- **Skipping the pilot.** A scale that has not been tested with real raters can hide unclear anchors until the results are already in use.
- **Leaving out rater training.** Even well-written anchors can produce inconsistent ratings when raters interpret them differently.
- **Leaving the scale unchanged for years.** Roles and tools change, and anchors can fall out of date.

## Frequently asked questions

### What is a behaviorally anchored rating scale?

A behaviorally anchored rating scale, or BARS, is a rating scale in which some or all levels are described with examples of observable behavior, so raters compare what they saw with the same descriptions.

### What is an example of a behaviorally anchored rating scale?

An example of a behaviorally anchored rating scale is a five-point scale for resolving customer complaints. A 5 describes acknowledging the customer's frustration and resolving the issue on first contact or following up to check the fix, and a 1 describes arguing with the customer or closing the case without resolving it. The three examples above show complete scales.

### How many points should a BARS have?

The number of points on a BARS usually ranges from five to seven. Five points with anchors at the ends and the middle are often enough; more points can add precision when raters are well trained and the anchors are clearly different from one another.

### How long does it take to build a BARS?

The time to build a BARS depends on the number of roles and dimensions, how many people contribute examples and whether the scale needs a formal pilot. A single scale for one role may come together far faster than a set of scales for an assessment center or a performance process across many roles.

### What is the difference between BARS and a graphic rating scale?

The difference between BARS and a graphic rating scale is how each level is defined. A graphic rating scale uses numbers or adjectives, such as "poor" to "excellent," while BARS describe what a person does at each level.

### Who should see BARS ratings?

We recommend sharing BARS ratings with the person rated, together with the anchors, so the rating becomes a conversation about the next level. Development ratings, including 360 results, are best kept between the person, their manager or coach and HR. Ratings used in hiring or other decisions follow the organization's selection and privacy policies.

## How to start building a behaviorally anchored rating scale

Start with the one dimension that matters most for a current decision or development goal. Collect a handful of real examples of effective and ineffective behavior from people who know the work, draft anchors for the ends and the middle of the scale and ask a few raters to try them on shared examples. Our [employee assessment tools](https://www.ppsinternational.net/assessments) page describes how PPS designs and administers assessments, and our guide to [choosing leadership assessment tools](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/choosing-the-right-leadership-assessments-for-your-priorities) and the [sales assessment center case](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/case-studies/sales-assessment-center-for-global-sales-professionals-a-case-study) are practical next resources.

Contact us if you are building anchored rating scales for an assessment center, a 360 or structured interviews and want help writing the anchors and training the people who use them.

[Start a conversation about assessments](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contact)

## References

1. Smith, P. C. and Kendall, L. M. (1963). Retranslation of expectations: An approach to the construction of unambiguous anchors for rating scales. Journal of Applied Psychology, 47(2), 149-155. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0047060
2. Landy, F. J. and Barnes, J. L. (1979). Scaling behavioral anchors. Applied Psychological Measurement, 3(2), 193-200. https://doi.org/10.1177/014662167900300209
3. Klieger, D. M., Kell, H. J., Rikoon, S. H., Burkander, K., Bochenek, J. L. and Shore, J. R. (2018). Development of the behaviorally anchored rating scales for the Skills Demonstration and Progression Guide. ETS Research Report Series, 2018(1), 1-36. https://doi.org/10.1002/ets2.12210
4. Sackett, P. R., Zhang, C., Berry, C. M. and Lievens, F. (2022). Revisiting meta-analytic estimates of validity in personnel selection: Addressing systematic overcorrection for restriction of range. Journal of Applied Psychology, 107(11), 2040-2068. https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0000994
5. Gorman, C. A., Jackson, D. J. R., Meriac, J. P., Himmler, J. R. and Contreras, T. F. (2024). Beyond rating accuracy: Unpacking frame-of-reference assessor training effectiveness. Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 17(2), 206-219. https://doi.org/10.1017/iop.2024.6

[Articles](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources?type=articles) [Sales & HR Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources?topic=sales-hr-development)

Continue learning

## Recent Resources

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-5638c535fdc78d8968bc.jpg) Article Stay Interviews: The Questions to Ask and How Managers Run Them](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/stay-interviews)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-6aee0114493fb1cfb7c3.jpg) Article Post-Training Survey Questions: 30 Questions and When to Ask Them](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/post-training-survey-questions)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-1939e0beea276e297f28.jpg) Article One-on-One Meeting Questions: 40 Questions Managers Can Ask, by Purpose](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/one-on-one-meeting-questions)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-f9d53d631281321ebe08.jpg) Article Skill-Will Matrix: How to Use It and What It Misses](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/skill-will-matrix)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/raw_assets/public/pps-international/assets/images/resources-hero.png) Article Self-Awareness in Leadership: Why It Matters and How to Build It](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/self-awareness-in-leadership)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/learning-retention-retrieval-practice-featured.jpg) Video Learning Retention: How Retrieval Practice Makes Training Stick](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/videos/learning-retention-retrieval-practice)

## We’re ready for you.

We enjoy discussing possibilities and approaches, so please reach out! Contact PPS International Limited today to explore how we can support your talent development initiatives.

[![PPS International Limited](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/raw_assets/public/pps-international/assets/images/footer-logo.svg)](https://www.ppsinternational.net/)

PPS International Limited is a trusted learning and development partner empowering teams of all sizes with leadership, communication, influence, sales and professional skills training that drives meaningful business results.

## Stay connected

Get practical learning and development insights from PPS.

## Contact

[+1 864-962-6789](tel:+18649626789)  
[info@PPS-SyNetAmericas.net](mailto:info@PPS-SyNetAmericas.net)

<https://www.facebook.com/PPSinternationalLtd> <https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCeHIccCo8DQh4jCffm5tlVQ> <https://www.linkedin.com/company/pps-international-limited/>

## Expertise

- [Leadership Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/leadership-development)
- [Talent Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/talent-development)
- [Communication & Influence](https://www.ppsinternational.net/communication-influence)
- [Change & Transition](https://www.ppsinternational.net/change-transition)
- [Sales & HR Effectiveness](https://www.ppsinternational.net/sales-hr-effectiveness)
- [Performance Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/performance-support)
- [Implementation Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/implementation-support)

## [Resources](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources)

## About

- [About PPS](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about)
- [Who We Serve](https://www.ppsinternational.net/who-we-serve)

## Solutions

- [Assessments](https://www.ppsinternational.net/assessments)
- [Contract Training & Facilitation](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contract-training-facilitation)
- [Coaching Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/coaching)
- [Instructional Design Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/instructional-design)
- [Interaction Styles](https://www.ppsinternational.net/interaction-styles)
- [Training Administration](https://www.ppsinternational.net/training-administration)
- [Training Programs](https://www.ppsinternational.net/programs)

## [Shop](https://shop.ppsinternational.net/)

© 2026 PPS International Limited. All rights reserved. [Privacy & Legal](https://www.ppsinternational.net/privacy)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Kelly Fairbairn"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-16T21:58:52Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-16T21:58:52Z",
  "description" : "A behaviorally anchored rating scale (BARS) describes what performance looks like at each level. See three examples and the steps to build your own.",
  "headline" : "Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scale (BARS): Examples and How to Build One",
  "image" : [ "https://51770148.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/51770148/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-a6574d51550a99f37e46.jpg" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/behaviorally-anchored-rating-scale",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.ppsinternational.net/#organization",
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "//51770148.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/51770148/raw_assets/public/pps-international/assets/images/footer-logo.svg"
    },
    "name" : "PPS International Limited"
  }
}
```