Choosing the Right Leadership Assessment Tools for Your Priorities

In the world of talent development, there are hundreds of leadership assessments. They fall into categories such as behavioral style profiles (Everything DiSC® and Interaction Styles®), personality assessments (Hogan and MBTI®), 360-degree feedback, skills-based inventories, simulations and more. These assessments are designed to reveal leadership styles, perceptions, strengths, potential and capability across a variety of factors.

Knowing there are hundreds of useful and valid leadership assessments, how can HR and talent development professionals choose the best for their leadership priorities? This guide describes the main types of leadership assessment tools and what each measures, the questions we use to narrow the choice, which tools fit which priority, how a leadership 360 works, how to assess leadership potential, the governance that keeps assessment fair and examples from our client work.

Types of leadership assessment tools

Most leadership assessment tools measure one of a few things: how a person prefers to behave, what they value and how they may derail under pressure, what they enjoy in a role, how others experience them or what they can actually do when observed. The table lists the types we use most, with examples from the instruments PPS International Limited administers:

TypeWhat It MeasuresExamples We UseBest For
Behavioral style profilesPreferred ways of interacting, communicating and influencing; ability to adapt to others' styles.Interaction Styles® and SOLO IS®, Everything DiSC® by Wiley, Insights Discovery®New and first-line managers, influence and communication programs, team development.
Personality and derailersDay-to-day personality, values and drivers, and the patterns that surface under stress.Hogan Assessments (HPI, MVPI and HDS), MBTI®, FIRO-B®Senior leader development, executive coaching, selection when the instrument is validated for it.
Work preferences and role fitWhat a person enjoys doing and therefore tends to do well, compared with the demands of a specific role.Harrison Assessment®, with job success formulas for the roleSelection, succession planning, coaching toward a target role.
Emotional intelligenceSelf-awareness, self-regulation, empathy and social skills in the workplace.EQ-i 2.0® by MHS, including the leadership reportCoaching engagements, high-potential leaders, sales and customer-facing leaders.
Conflict and organizational savvyTypical responses to conflict; ability to read and work within organizational politics.Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument (TKI), Organizational Savvy self-assessmentInfluence programs, HR business partner development, leaders new to matrixed organizations.
StrengthsTalents and character strengths a leader can build on.CliftonStrengths® by Gallup, VIA character strengthsEngagement, team building, individual development plans.
360-degree feedbackHow the manager, peers, direct reports and customers perceive the leader against defined behaviors, compared with self-perception.Customized 360s built on the organization's competencies or values; off-the-shelf versions such as the Lockwood Leadership Assessment®Leader development at every level, program baselines and follow-up measurement.
Simulations and assessment centersObserved behavior in realistic situations: coaching conversations, sales calls, business cases and group exercises.Custom simulations, live and virtual assessment centers, the LVI® as part of a centerIdentifying potential, selection for critical roles, sales and leadership pipelines.
Structured interviewsAspirations, commitment, experience and the gaps instruments do not cover.Interview guides built for the program, conducted by trained assessorsSuccession conversations, assessment center close-out, career planning.
Skills and competency inventoriesSelf- or manager-rated proficiency against a competency model, usually at group level.Customized surveys and training needs assessmentsProgram design, prioritizing which capabilities to build first.

Keep in mind that a leadership style quiz taken by an individual for curiosity and a leadership assessment used by an organization for development or selection are different things, even when the instrument is the same. The difference is what happens with the results, which is the subject of most of this article.

Questions to help choose leadership assessments

Here are a few questions to answer in order to narrow down your leadership assessment choices.

  • What do I want to uncover or reinforce through this assessment? Assessments can be useful in reinforcing and identifying developmental goals. They provide information that can help to justify or provide a starting point for conversations about performance and capabilities. The most important aspect of working with assessments is to match your goal to the assessment. The more clearly you know what you would like to measure, the easier it is to select and implement an effective assessment. Be specific.
  • What data and information do I already have versus what I need? Performance reviews, evaluations, observations and discussions provide insights into capabilities and skills. Where data already exists, use it. If gaps or areas of contrasting information are present, consider those to be potential areas where assessments could provide clarity. Lean into the data available. Assessments can be intrusive and labor-intensive, so capitalizing on information that is already available is helpful in managing resources.
  • Do I need the leadership assessment to be tailored to the role or individual, or is something off-the-shelf sufficient? Customized assessments, especially those that uncover fit for role or provide 360 feedback, are most valuable if they reflect the specific job or the competencies and values that are expected of an individual. Generic assessments can be helpful if the skills and competencies you are measuring are fairly universal.
  • Does my organization have preferences on what assessment I use? Many organizations have pre-selected, readily available leadership assessments. While it is possible that a non-approved assessment would be useful, there is a lot to be said for aligning with processes and assessments that are already in place. Often, company-approved assessments come with comparative data and built-in resources that match uncovered needs to available learning and development resources.
  • Will the results be used for development only, or also for selection and promotion? An instrument used for selection has to be validated for that purpose and tied to success in the role without cultural or other bias. Many development instruments are not, and using them for a promotion decision exposes the organization and undermines trust in the process.
  • Who will see the results, and what will they be told about how the results are used? Participants ask this on day one. Decide before the assessment is administered who receives the report, how long it is stored and whether there is a "pass" or "fail," and put the answers in the communication that introduces the assessment.

Matching the assessment to the priority

The question we hear most often is not "which assessment is best" but "which assessment is best for this." Here is how the tools tend to line up with common leadership priorities:

Leadership PriorityTools That FitWhy
Developing new and first-line managersA behavioral style profile with a group debrief, then a 360 after 12 to 18 months in roleNew managers benefit most from seeing how their style lands with people unlike themselves; a 360 in the first months measures a role they have not yet learned.
Building a leadership pipeline and identifying potentialWork preference assessment, a simulation or assessment center, a structured interview and existing performance dataPotential is a prediction, so it needs more than one source; observed behavior and stated aspirations correct for the reputation effect in nominations.
Preparing a leader for a larger role360 feedback plus a personality and derailer assessment, debriefed by a coachThe larger role changes which preferences help and which hurt; the pairing shows both the perception and the pattern behind it.
Improving how a leadership team works togetherA team survey and a shared style profile, with a facilitated debriefTeam functioning is a group measure; individual reports alone rarely change how the team operates.
Selecting leaders from outsideOnly instruments validated for selection, with role-specific templates, structured interviews and a simulation for critical rolesSelection carries legal and fairness obligations that development may not.
Supporting a coaching engagementEmotional intelligence, personality and 360 results, chosen with the coachThe coach needs a starting picture; the leader needs a reason to believe it.
Developing sales leaders and sales representativesA sales call simulation, a customized 360 and a preference instrument such as Interaction Styles® or Everything DiSC®Sales populations trust assessments that look like their work and assessors with sales backgrounds.

How a leadership 360 assessment works

A 360 leadership assessment gathers anonymous feedback from the people around a leader, typically the manager, peers, direct reports and sometimes internal or external customers, on a defined set of behaviors, and compares it with the leader's self-rating. It is the most widely used leadership assessment tool for development because it measures the thing development is meant to change, which is how the leader is experienced by others. Here is the process we follow with clients:

  1. Define the behaviors. Build the items from the organization's competency model or values, or select an off-the-shelf version that fits the role. Fewer, more specific items produce better data than a long generic list.
  2. Communicate the purpose. Tell leaders and raters what the results will be used for, who will see them and how anonymity is protected, before the invitations to participate go out.
  3. Choose raters. A manager, four to eight peers and direct reports and, where relevant, customers; set a minimum number of responses per rater group so that no individual can be identified.
  4. Administer within a defined window. Most versions take 30 minutes or less to complete, including open-ended questions, and are available in multiple languages for global cohorts.
  5. Debrief one on one. A trained facilitator or coach walks the leader through the report, with attention to the gaps between self and others and to the themes in the open-ended comments.
  6. Turn it into a development plan. Focus on two or three behaviors, with plans to share themes with people who gave the feedback.
  7. Re-measure. A second 360 at 12 to 18 months shows whether the perception moved, which can also be evidence that coaching or a development program changed behavior.

Two cautions from our experience. First, a 360 built for development should not be used for compensation or promotion decisions; 360s measure perceptions and are not appropriate for employment-related decisions. Second, a 360 needs a debrief to be effective. Without a debrief and a plan it is unlikely any change will take place.

Assessing leadership potential

Assessing leadership potential requires different criteria than evaluating current performance. Organizations that conflate the two risk promoting top individual contributors into roles that demand entirely different strengths. Potential is a prediction about a larger or different role, so we look for evidence from several sources:

  • Performance data, as a threshold.
  • A work preference assessment compared with the target role, since people tend to do well with what they enjoy doing.
  • Observed behavior in a simulation or assessment center, where the person handles situations the target role requires.
  • A structured interview about aspirations and commitment, because potential without desire can create frustration for the individual and the organization.
  • Calibrated manager nominations, discussed as a group so that a single manager's reputation-based view does not overshadow all other inputs.

In a sales assessment center for a high-growth, global medical technology organization, this combination of a client-specific 360, the LVI®, the Harrison Assessment®, the EQ-i® and individual interviews identified high-potential sales representatives able to move into leadership, and highly skilled representatives who could mentor less tenured peers, with a consistent debrief and coaching process from region to region. The results of an exercise like this belong in the organization's succession planning process, where the assessment answers the "who is ready" question and the development plan answers "ready for what, and by when."

Working with multiple assessments

Even with clarity and access to leadership assessments, it can be difficult to achieve your goals with a single solution. Sometimes the best approach is to use a combination of assessments. For instance, a leader might benefit from understanding perceptions from direct reports and peers through a 360-feedback instrument, while also knowing how their preferences may be detrimental in a higher-level role. High-potential individual contributors may demonstrate formal leadership skills during a simulation, yet share career goals more readily in a structured interview. Using a variety of leadership assessments can be useful in development. A few keys to success in using multiple assessments, without creating "assessment overwhelm," are to:

  • Take the time to be sure your leaders understand the purpose and features of each assessment before beginning the assessment process.
  • Work with a single vendor to administer the assessments in order to streamline your back-end operations.
  • Have a plan to analyze and debrief the results of the assessments, with a specific focus on culling information from all sources into a single summary with supporting resources.

These strategies help to ensure that your leadership assessments produce a high return on investment.

Validity, fairness and data governance

The assessment itself is rarely where an implementation goes wrong. Here are the practices that are important to an effective assessment process:

  • Use instruments validated for the decision being made. Development instruments describe; selection instruments need to predict.
  • Watch for cultural and personality bias in observed exercises. Eye contact, directness and greeting behaviors vary by culture and by neurodiversity, and observers need to know which differences are not deficits.
  • Separate the assessment and debrief from the use of the results. In our experience, participants tend to trust external assessors over internal ones, not because internal people are less skilled but because they carry history, relationships and the authority to make career decisions.
  • Share results back to participants. It is our strong belief that a person who completes an assessment is entitled to understand what it says, with someone qualified to explain it.
  • Define data governance before administration: who sees results, how long they are stored, whether group reports are anonymized and how results are used after the program ends.
  • Treat generative AI as a supplement, not the author. AI tools can help compile observation notes and draft summaries, but an assessor should own the interpretation and the report.

Leadership assessment examples from our work

Here are a few examples of how the tools above have been combined for specific priorities:

  • New sales leaders in a large, technically focused global organization completed SOLO IS® with a group debrief as part of a four-day new manager development program, giving 200 first-line managers across six regions a shared language for the coaching and feedback skills the program taught.
  • Career engineers with a sales target at a large North American engineering firm were assessed with a customized 360 built on a new competency model; the group analysis revealed organizational skill strengths and gaps, produced the firm's first individual development plans and equipped managers to develop their teams.
  • Leaders in a global organization from more than 11 countries, operating under constant change completed an assessment that revealed common development needs in learning agility and tolerance for ambiguity, which became the design for a leading-through-ambiguity program which included a baseline assessment, peer feedback and on-the-job reference tools.
  • Middle managers who were research scientists at a North American electronics manufacturer used a customized assessment and the organization's global coaching model inside a multi-month curriculum, then created individual development plans and led their own team members through the same exercise. More than 100 leaders completed the development and reported 81% improvement in confidence to coach their teams.
  • HR business partners at a U.S. defense subcontractor completed the Organizational Savvy self-assessment at the start of a nine-month development journey, which focused their work on internal consulting and influence with senior leaders. 91% of those in HR roles completed the assessment, with several cascading across five business units, touching nearly 700 employees, customers and subcontractors across the business.

Frequently asked questions

What are the main types of leadership assessment tools?

The main types of leadership assessment tools are behavioral style profiles, personality and derailer assessments, work preference and role-fit assessments, emotional intelligence inventories, conflict and organizational savvy instruments, strengths assessments, 360-degree feedback, simulations and assessment centers, structured interviews and skills or competency inventories. Most organizations use two or three types together rather than one.

What is a 360 leadership assessment?

A 360 leadership assessment is a survey in which a leader's manager, peers, direct reports and sometimes customers rate the leader anonymously on defined behaviors, with the results compared with the leader's self-rating and debriefed into a development plan. It measures how a leader is experienced by others, which is what development is meant to change.

How do you assess leadership potential?

Measure leadership potential with more than one source: performance as a threshold, a work preference assessment compared with the target role, observed behavior in a simulation or assessment center, a structured interview about aspirations and calibrated manager nominations. A single nomination or a single instrument tends to reward reputation rather than readiness.

Can leadership assessments be used for hiring and promotion decisions?

Some leadership assessments can be used for hiring and promotion decisions, provided the instrument is validated for selection and tied to success in the role. Most development instruments, including 360s, should not be used for those decisions; the moment raters or participants know a promotion depends on the result, the data changes.

How much does a leadership assessment cost?

The cost of a leadership assessment depends on the instrument and the service around it. Off-the-shelf profiles are priced per participant, 360s per participant with group reports priced separately, customization of a 360 as a one-time cost, and simulations and assessment centers by the scope of the design and the number of assessors. Debriefing and coaching are usually the larger part of the investment, and the part that determines whether the assessment changes anything.

How often should leaders be assessed?

Style and personality profiles rarely need repeating each year; a leader's preferences tend to be stable. A 360 is worth repeating at 12 to 18 months after a development program to measure change, and again at a transition into a larger role. Assessment for potential belongs on the succession planning calendar, typically annually for the roles that are mission critical.

What is the difference between a leadership assessment and a leadership style quiz?

A leadership quiz gives an individual a label. A leadership assessment gives an organization and a leader a shared, validated picture that feeds a decision or a development plan, with a debrief, a plan and often a re-measure. The same instrument can be either, depending on what is done with the results.

Where to start

Start by determining what you want to uncover or reinforce, stated as specifically as you can. The tool you choose will be selected based upon your answer. In general, if you work with a vendor who offers many assessment options, they have a better range to match your need to the instrument. We administer thousands of assessments to leaders around the world, with more than 15,000 assessment takers a year participating in a survey. As part of this, we facilitate one-on-one and group debriefing sessions, tapping into our network of more than 200 consultants around the world. For customization support, we design full-scale assessment centers for development and selection. Learn more about our employee and leadership assessments.

Contact us if you want help choosing assessments for your priorities, running the debriefs or designing an assessment center.

Start a conversation about leadership assessments

We’re ready for you.

We enjoy discussing possibilities and approaches, so please reach out! Contact PPS International Limited today to explore how we can support your talent development initiatives.