---
title: "Learning Agility in Leaders: A Case Study and Guide | PPS International"
description: What learning agility and tolerance for ambiguity are, how to assess and develop them, and a case study of leaders who learned to lead through ambiguity.
image: https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-01e042fce90ae4b2549d.jpg
---

[Skip to main content](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/case-studies/increasing-leaders-ability-to-lead-through-ambiguity-case-study#main-content)

[![PPS International Limited](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/raw_assets/public/pps-international/assets/images/logo.svg)](https://www.ppsinternational.net/)

[Expertise](https://www.ppsinternational.net/expertise)

[Leadership Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/leadership-development) [Talent Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/talent-development) [Communication & Influence](https://www.ppsinternational.net/communication-influence) [Change & Transition](https://www.ppsinternational.net/change-transition) [Sales & HR Effectiveness](https://www.ppsinternational.net/sales-hr-effectiveness) [Performance Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/performance-support) [Implementation Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/implementation-support)

[Solutions](https://www.ppsinternational.net/solutions)

[Assessments](https://www.ppsinternational.net/assessments) [Contract Training & Facilitation](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contract-training-facilitation) [Coaching Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/coaching) [Instructional Design Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/instructional-design) [Interaction Styles](https://www.ppsinternational.net/interaction-styles) [Training Administration](https://www.ppsinternational.net/training-administration) [Training Programs](https://www.ppsinternational.net/programs)

[Shop](https://shop.ppsinternational.net/) [Resources](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources)

[About](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about)

[About PPS](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about) [Who We Serve](https://www.ppsinternational.net/who-we-serve)

[Get in touch](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contact)

Search the site

Search

Search the site

Search

Expertise

[Explore all expertise](https://www.ppsinternational.net/expertise) [Leadership Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/leadership-development) [Talent Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/talent-development) [Communication & Influence](https://www.ppsinternational.net/communication-influence) [Change & Transition](https://www.ppsinternational.net/change-transition) [Sales & HR Effectiveness](https://www.ppsinternational.net/sales-hr-effectiveness) [Performance Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/performance-support) [Implementation Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/implementation-support)

Solutions

[Explore all solutions](https://www.ppsinternational.net/solutions) [Assessments](https://www.ppsinternational.net/assessments) [Contract Training & Facilitation](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contract-training-facilitation) [Coaching Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/coaching) [Instructional Design Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/instructional-design) [Interaction Styles](https://www.ppsinternational.net/interaction-styles) [Training Administration](https://www.ppsinternational.net/training-administration) [Training Programs](https://www.ppsinternational.net/programs)

Explore

[Resources](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources) [About PPS](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about) [Who We Serve](https://www.ppsinternational.net/who-we-serve) [Shop](https://shop.ppsinternational.net/) [Get in touch](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contact)

Case Study [Change & Transition](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources?topic=change-transition) Updated October 8, 2026 First published September 22, 2025 By [Kelly Fairbairn](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about/kelly-fairbairn)

# Learning Agility in Leaders: A Leading Through Ambiguity Case Study and Guide

![An orange question mark stands out among scattered gray question marks.](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hs-fs/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-01e042fce90ae4b2549d.jpg?width=680&height=572&name=pps-resource-01e042fce90ae4b2549d.jpg)

Leaders are asked to make decisions with partial data, adapt quickly to changing conditions and offer recommendations without complete clarity. The capability behind that is learning agility, supported by a tolerance for ambiguity, and both can be assessed and developed. This page explains what learning agility is, shares a case study in which PPS International Limited helped a global medical device organization build leaders who could lead through ambiguity, and describes how to assess the capability, how to design development that builds it and how to measure the change.

## What is learning agility?

Learning agility is the ability to learn from experience and apply the lessons to new and first-time situations. The term comes from Lombardo and Eichinger's research on high potentials, which found that the leaders who succeeded in unfamiliar roles were the ones who learned the right lessons from experience and used them when the situation was new \[1\]. They described four dimensions:

- Mental agility: comfort with complexity, examining problems carefully and making connections between different elements.
- People agility: knowing oneself well, [staying calm and flexible under pressure](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/taking-the-heat-of-leadership) and building constructive relationships with different kinds of people.
- Change agility: curiosity, openness and a willingness to experiment.
- Results agility: delivering under difficult, first-time conditions and inspiring others to perform.

Tolerance for ambiguity is a related trait. Budner defined intolerance of ambiguity as "the tendency to perceive ambiguous situations as sources of threat," and tolerance of ambiguity as the tendency to perceive them as desirable \[2\]. Leaders with higher tolerance treat the same situations as workable, or even interesting. In our experience the two co-exist. A leader who finds ambiguity threatening tends to wait for data that is not coming, while a leader with mental and change agility keeps moving with what is known and updates as the picture changes.

There are conditions that drive a need for leaders to have learning agility. VUCA (volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous) has described the operating environment since the late 1980s, and Cascio's BANI framing (brittle, anxious, nonlinear and incomprehensible) captures what many leaders experienced after 2020 \[3\]. Frameworks are useful for describing elements of the environment that benefit from having strong skills in learning agility. Frameworks alone don't build the capability, which is why the case below was built around practice rather than concepts.

## A leading through ambiguity case study

### Situation

Our Asia-Pacific-based client organization is operating in a highly competitive, price-sensitive, emerging market, producing highly regulated medical devices used by surgeons in established and emerging healthcare facilities. Using assessments, their Human Resources team validated some of the challenges seen in those in client-facing roles: leaders need to make decisions to solve patient health concerns, while also managing hospital and clinic investments. During the business development cycle, individuals have access to limited data. They also need to demonstrate adaptability to changing priorities, showing a tolerance for ambiguity and ability to learn in a changing environment.

### Desired outcomes

- Confidently make recommendations to meet client needs and achieve patient outcomes, sometimes with limited data and information.
- Increase sale of products while also achieving regulatory compliance, yielding improved patient outcomes and reduced healthcare capital expenditures and consumable expenses for clients.
- Improve abilities of leaders, sales professionals and others through experience and knowledge-sharing with colleagues; improve collective knowledge and skills.
- Reduce the turnaround time on decisions and recommendations for both internal and external decisions.

### Our solution

We designed an experiential, case-based workshop that required participants to work in small teams to respond directly to a realistic strategic business challenge. The data and insights that participants received pre-workshop changed during the experience, in order to simulate evolving data.

The workshop included a preparation task to review available data on the case, then, over two days of in-person facilitated sessions, participants created recommendations, researched additional data needed and managed changing customer priorities. After each working case round, participants discussed their insights, mindset, process and decisions.

Post-workshop, participants attended client-run learning circles and used a Learning through Experience guide, reinforcement videos and a developmental activities checklist created specifically for the client with curated resources.

### Products and services

- [Needs analysis](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/training-needs-assessment) and consultation services to create a design strategy that met client goals and resource budget.
- Custom instructional design and development, including working with subject matter experts to create detailed, data-rich cases.
- Facilitation services, using experiential methodologies in cross-functional groups.
- Performance support through toolkits, demonstration videos and checklists.

### Success indicators

The *Leading Through Ambiguity* initiative employed a combination of quantitative and qualitative data to assess impact and ensure meaningful outcomes. Key success indicators included:

- Baseline assessment of target skills (later used for comparison).
- Peer feedback in social learning settings.
- Learning journal reflections about behavior change.

Post-program evaluation results included:

- Content relevance to role: 3.81 of 4.
- Learned new skills: 3.81 of 4.
- Intent to apply skills: 3.69 of 4.

[Download the Increasing Leaders' Ability to Lead Through Ambiguity case study](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/downloads/pps-resource-d5e4cd0ab56e31c82dea.pdf) as a one-page brief.

### What made it work

Looking back at this engagement, a few design decisions contributed to success:

- The data changed while participants were working with it. A case with static data focuses on analysis; a case whose customer priorities and available information shift between rounds teaches the behavior the client needed, which was deciding and recommending before the picture was complete.
- The case was real to participants. Subject matter experts helped build a data-rich case from the organization's own market, regulatory constraints and customer types, so the practice looked like the job.
- Cross-functional teams practiced together. Leaders, sales professionals and others who make and receive recommendations in real life worked the case together, which built the collective knowledge the client asked for and made the debriefs candid.
- Every round ended with a debrief of mindset and process, not only the decision. Participants examined how they had reacted to the ambiguity, which is where tolerance for ambiguity is actually built.
- The program did not end with the workshop. Client-run learning circles, the *Learning through Experience* guide, reinforcement videos and the developmental activities checklist kept the practice going in the flow of work.

## How to assess learning agility and tolerance for ambiguity

The client began with assessment. This is what we suggest as a strong starting point. A baseline tells you which leaders and which dimensions need the work, gives the program a design brief and provides the comparison point for measuring change later. Here are the methods we use, often in combination:

- Self-report instruments that measure learning agility dimensions or tolerance for ambiguity, useful for self-awareness and for identifying group trends. This is the primary means of assessment the client in our case used to uncover broader needs, including a need for learning agility and tolerance for ambiguity.
- 360-degree feedback items structured around the behaviors associated with learning agility and tolerance for ambiguity makes decisions with incomplete information, adjusts plans when conditions change, seeks out unfamiliar assignments, asks for and uses feedback.
- Simulations and assessment center exercises in which the information changes mid-exercise, observed by trained assessors against a defined checklist. Observed behavior under ambiguity predicts on-the-job behavior better than a description of it. While this was not a pre-assessment means, it was key to understanding if participants were building skills in the moment for our case.
- Structured interviews about first-time situations: what the leader did when the role, the market or the data was new, and what they learned from it.
- Existing performance data and manager observation, used as the threshold rather than the answer.

Keep in mind that the results are development data. Share them back with participants, separate the assessment debrief from any decision about roles and use external assessors where the organization's history would color internal judgments. Our guide to [choosing leadership assessment tools](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/choosing-the-right-leadership-assessments-for-your-priorities) covers how to match instruments to the priority, and our [assessment services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/assessments) include design and administration of assessment centers.

## How to develop leaders who can lead through ambiguity

Learning agility develops through experience with feedback, which means the design has to create experiences rather than describe them. Here are a few guidelines that help to structure the learning journey:

1. Design practice-based programs. Structure the learning journey around realistic organizational cases with data supplied by subject matter experts, ensuring leaders practice in scenarios mirroring their actual work environment. Teach scenario planning as a working method, not a concept: name what is known, what is unknown and what would change the recommendation, and decide what to do under each plausible outcome. Our [scenario planning workshop](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/programs/future-proofing-scenario-planning) builds this method with leadership teams.
2. Implement learning in the flow of work that includes real-time debriefs on the job. Discuss what is being learned and how on the job to continuously connect daily experiences with ambiguity management skills.
3. Make reflection a habit with a learning journal, so the learning cycle continues after the workshop. Our article on [journaling for leaders](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/3-reasons-journaling-builds-better-leaders) describes how.
4. For any formal learning programs, be sure to plan application supports. For instance, assignments in the flow of work, short reinforcement videos and a checklist of developmental activities with curated resources. Our article on [reinforcing training](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/11-ways-to-reinforce-training) lists the options and a cadence for the year.
5. Implement structured "red team" exercises. This might include assigning a peer group to actively challenge assumptions and poke holes in strategic proposals, forcing leaders to defend and adapt their plans under unexpected pushback and raising up ways for them to also test assumptions in ambiguous situations.
6. Incorporate rapid time-boxed decision drills. This could look like subjecting leaders to low-stakes, high-uncertainty scenarios with strict time limits to break analysis paralysis and build a reliable bias for prompt action.
7. Pair leaders with specialized coaches. These coaches can provide targeted one-on-one coaching focused specifically on navigating ambiguity, helping leaders process real-time workplace uncertainties and build personalized strategies for adaptive decision-making.

Peer structures can outlast the program. When PPS International Limited designed a 15-month development program for a global financial services organization, we built structured networking and action learning groups to support on-the-job application, and at a three-year check-in nearly 50% of the groups were still meeting, even when members were in new roles and in some cases new organizations. Learning circles serve the same purpose for leaders practicing under ambiguity: a place to bring a live situation, hear how peers are reading it and commit to the next move.

## What leaders who lead well through ambiguity do

The client's desired outcomes define the target behaviors, serving as the foundation for assessment, case design and measurement. Leaders who lead well through ambiguity tend to:

- Exhibit comfort with ambiguity and make decisions or recommendations with limited information, then adjust as more arrives.
- [Respond to change and flux with confidence](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/change-leadership) rather than waiting for stability.
- Make space for ideation when solving problems and consider alternatives rather than the conventional or immediate choice.
- Take in divergent views, even those not immediately applicable.
- Engage in, and encourage, sensible risk taking, accepting that some choices lead to failure and that failure can lead to learning.
- Communicate what is known, what is not and what the team will do next, so that others can act without false certainty.

For an individual leader looking for day-to-day practices, our tool [six ways to deal with ambiguity](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/guides/tool-6-ways-to-deal-with-ambiguity) is a good starting place, and our video on [leading in a VUCA world](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/videos/how-can-we-deal-with-the-complexity-of-the-unknown) addresses complexity and uncertainty at the organizational level.

## Measuring the change

Because the client assessed before the program, it could measure after it. Here is the measurement structure we suggest, which follows the case:

- Baseline assessment of the target skills, repeated after the reinforcement period for comparison.
- Peer feedback in the learning circles, captured against the same behaviors.
- Learning journal reflections about behavior change, reviewed for themes.
- Post-program evaluation of relevance, skills learned and intent to apply, which in this case ran 3.81, 3.81 and 3.69 of 4.
- Business measures the program was designed to move: turnaround time on decisions and recommendations, and the quality of recommendations made with limited data as judged by the leaders who receive them.

Our guide to [measuring leadership development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/does-your-leadership-training-actually-work-measuring-outcomes-for-learning) describes how to set the measures before the first cohort.

## Where learning agility programs fall short

Here is what we have learned about the failure points when organizations set out to build capability in learning agility and leading through ambiguity:

- Not including an element of self-knowledge and preferences in the overall learning process. Learning agility and dealing with ambiguity are highly tied to an individual's working style and behavioral preferences. This is important to acknowledge and address in formal learning.
- Teaching the frameworks and stopping without practice and application. VUCA and BANI explain the environment; they do not change how a leader behaves. Leaders need to practice behaviors to have confidence to try those out on the job.
- No structure after workshops. Without learning circles, assignments and reinforcement, leaders revert to old habits. Learning agility and dealing with ambiguity are most effectively practiced and learned in real-time. The workshop is important for grounding the behaviors and providing techniques to leaders who need to have their comfort boundaries pushed on this topic, but application and learning in the flow of work afterward are critical to long-term change.
- Not considering organizational systems and structures that inadvertently reward consistency and knowing. Traditional performance appraisals, KPIs and incentive structures typically reward compliance, precision and error-free delivery rather than experimental problem-solving. To build learning agility and leading through ambiguity, consider culture initiatives that will help to unfreeze these ingrained conditions.

## Frequently asked questions

### What does leading through ambiguity mean?

Leading through ambiguity means making decisions and recommendations, and keeping a team moving, when the information is incomplete, the conditions are changing and there is no clear answer. It requires learning agility, meaning the ability to learn from experience and apply it to first-time situations, and a tolerance for ambiguity, meaning the capacity to treat unclear situations as workable rather than threatening.

### Can learning agility be developed?

In our experience, yes, leaders and others can improve learning agility through practice under realistic scenarios with feedback and reflection, followed by structure that keeps the practice going on the job. Some people start with more of it than others, which is what the baseline assessment shows, and the development design should account for that spread.

### How do you assess learning agility?

You can assess learning agility with a combination of a self-report instrument, 360 items written for the specific behaviors, observed simulations in which the information changes and structured interviews about first-time situations, compared with performance data. The baseline can become the comparison point for measuring any programs or other development.

### What is the difference between learning agility and tolerance for ambiguity?

Tolerance for ambiguity is a disposition: how a person experiences unclear situations. Learning agility is a set of behaviors: how quickly and flexibly a person learns from experience and applies it. Development programs work on both, by making ambiguity familiar through practice and by building the habits of reflection and adjustment.

### How long does a program like this take?

A program on learning agility and leading through ambiguity requires time to practice and apply. The case above ran a preparation task, two days of facilitated work and several months of learning circles and reinforcement. Plan for the reinforcement period to be longer than the workshop, since that is where the behavior sets in.

### Who should participate?

The people who make and receive recommendations under uncertainty, which in this case included leaders, sales professionals and others in client-facing roles, working together in cross-functional teams. Including intact teams where possible lets the practice transfer directly to the work.

## Where to start

Start with an assessment of the leaders who face the most ambiguity. This will guide the design of learning solutions. PPS International Limited supports organizations through [change and transition](https://www.ppsinternational.net/change-transition) with assessments, custom case-based programs and the performance support that keeps new behaviors in place. [Discuss your leaders' readiness for ambiguity with us](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contact).

[Start a conversation about leading through ambiguity](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contact)

## References

1. Lombardo, M. M., and Eichinger, R. W. (2000). High potentials as high learners. Human Resource Management, 39(4), 321–329.
2. Budner, S. (1962). Intolerance of ambiguity as a personality variable. Journal of Personality, 30(1), 29–50. doi:10.1111/j.1467-6494.1962.tb02303.x
3. Cascio, J. (2020). Facing the Age of Chaos. Medium, April 29, 2020. https://medium.com/@cascio/facing-the-age-of-chaos-b00687b1f51d

[Change & Transition](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources?topic=change-transition) [Case Studies](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources?type=case-studies)

Continue learning

## Recent Resources

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-5638c535fdc78d8968bc.jpg) Article Stay Interviews: The Questions to Ask and How Managers Run Them](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/stay-interviews)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-ac7b61a27597d851f8fa.jpg) Article Post-Training Survey Questions: 30 Questions and When to Ask Them](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/post-training-survey-questions)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-1939e0beea276e297f28.jpg) Article One-on-One Meeting Questions: 40 Questions Managers Can Ask, by Purpose](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/one-on-one-meeting-questions)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-a6574d51550a99f37e46.jpg) Article Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scale (BARS): Examples and How to Build One](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/behaviorally-anchored-rating-scale)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-f9d53d631281321ebe08.jpg) Article Skill-Will Matrix: How to Use It and What It Misses](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/skill-will-matrix)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-fdeb7ac7e4924f1e6380.jpg) Article Self-Awareness in Leadership: Why It Matters and How to Build It](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/self-awareness-in-leadership)

## We’re ready for you.

We enjoy discussing possibilities and approaches, so please reach out! Contact PPS International Limited today to explore how we can support your talent development initiatives.

[![PPS International Limited](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/raw_assets/public/pps-international/assets/images/footer-logo.svg)](https://www.ppsinternational.net/)

PPS International Limited is a trusted learning and development partner empowering teams of all sizes with leadership, communication, influence, sales and professional skills training that drives meaningful business results.

## Stay connected

Get practical learning and development insights from PPS.

## Contact

[+1 864-962-6789](tel:+18649626789)  
[info@PPS-SyNetAmericas.net](mailto:info@PPS-SyNetAmericas.net)

<https://www.facebook.com/PPSinternationalLtd> <https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCeHIccCo8DQh4jCffm5tlVQ> <https://www.linkedin.com/company/pps-international-limited/>

## Expertise

- [Leadership Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/leadership-development)
- [Talent Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/talent-development)
- [Communication & Influence](https://www.ppsinternational.net/communication-influence)
- [Change & Transition](https://www.ppsinternational.net/change-transition)
- [Sales & HR Effectiveness](https://www.ppsinternational.net/sales-hr-effectiveness)
- [Performance Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/performance-support)
- [Implementation Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/implementation-support)

## [Resources](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources)

## About

- [About PPS](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about)
- [Who We Serve](https://www.ppsinternational.net/who-we-serve)

## Solutions

- [Assessments](https://www.ppsinternational.net/assessments)
- [Contract Training & Facilitation](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contract-training-facilitation)
- [Coaching Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/coaching)
- [Instructional Design Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/instructional-design)
- [Interaction Styles](https://www.ppsinternational.net/interaction-styles)
- [Training Administration](https://www.ppsinternational.net/training-administration)
- [Training Programs](https://www.ppsinternational.net/programs)

## [Shop](https://shop.ppsinternational.net/)

© 2026 PPS International Limited. All rights reserved. [Privacy & Legal](https://www.ppsinternational.net/privacy)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Kelly Fairbairn"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-10-08T12:00:00Z",
  "datePublished" : "2025-09-22T12:00:00Z",
  "description" : "What learning agility and tolerance for ambiguity are, how to assess and develop them, and a case study of leaders who learned to lead through ambiguity.",
  "headline" : "Learning Agility in Leaders: A Leading Through Ambiguity Case Study and Guide",
  "image" : [ "https://51770148.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/51770148/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-01e042fce90ae4b2549d.jpg" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/case-studies/increasing-leaders-ability-to-lead-through-ambiguity-case-study",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.ppsinternational.net/#organization",
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "//51770148.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/51770148/raw_assets/public/pps-international/assets/images/footer-logo.svg"
    },
    "name" : "PPS International Limited"
  }
}
```