---
title: "Skill-Will Matrix: How to Use It and What It Misses | PPS International"
description: The skill-will matrix helps managers decide how to coach someone on a task. Learn the four quadrants, use the template and see what the matrix misses.
image: https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-f9d53d631281321ebe08.jpg
---

[Skip to main content](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/skill-will-matrix#main-content)

[![PPS International Limited](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/raw_assets/public/pps-international/assets/images/logo.svg)](https://www.ppsinternational.net/)

[Expertise](https://www.ppsinternational.net/expertise)

[Leadership Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/leadership-development) [Talent Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/talent-development) [Communication & Influence](https://www.ppsinternational.net/communication-influence) [Change & Transition](https://www.ppsinternational.net/change-transition) [Sales & HR Effectiveness](https://www.ppsinternational.net/sales-hr-effectiveness) [Performance Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/performance-support) [Implementation Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/implementation-support)

[Solutions](https://www.ppsinternational.net/solutions)

[Assessments](https://www.ppsinternational.net/assessments) [Contract Training & Facilitation](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contract-training-facilitation) [Coaching Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/coaching) [Instructional Design Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/instructional-design) [Interaction Styles](https://www.ppsinternational.net/interaction-styles) [Training Administration](https://www.ppsinternational.net/training-administration) [Training Programs](https://www.ppsinternational.net/programs)

[Shop](https://shop.ppsinternational.net/) [Resources](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources)

[About](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about)

[About PPS](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about) [Who We Serve](https://www.ppsinternational.net/who-we-serve)

[Get in touch](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contact)

Search the site

Search

Search the site

Search

Expertise

[Explore all expertise](https://www.ppsinternational.net/expertise) [Leadership Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/leadership-development) [Talent Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/talent-development) [Communication & Influence](https://www.ppsinternational.net/communication-influence) [Change & Transition](https://www.ppsinternational.net/change-transition) [Sales & HR Effectiveness](https://www.ppsinternational.net/sales-hr-effectiveness) [Performance Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/performance-support) [Implementation Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/implementation-support)

Solutions

[Explore all solutions](https://www.ppsinternational.net/solutions) [Assessments](https://www.ppsinternational.net/assessments) [Contract Training & Facilitation](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contract-training-facilitation) [Coaching Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/coaching) [Instructional Design Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/instructional-design) [Interaction Styles](https://www.ppsinternational.net/interaction-styles) [Training Administration](https://www.ppsinternational.net/training-administration) [Training Programs](https://www.ppsinternational.net/programs)

Explore

[Resources](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources) [About PPS](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about) [Who We Serve](https://www.ppsinternational.net/who-we-serve) [Shop](https://shop.ppsinternational.net/) [Get in touch](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contact)

Article [Leadership Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources?topic=leadership-development) November 16, 2026 By [Kelly Fairbairn](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about/kelly-fairbairn)

# Skill-Will Matrix: How to Use It and What It Misses

The skill-will matrix is a coaching model that helps a manager decide how to coach someone on a specific task. It compares how much skill the person brings to the task with how much will, or willingness, they bring to it. Each combination points to a coaching approach, from directing someone who is new to a task to delegating to someone who is capable and committed.

The model is popular because it is simple and gives managers a practical alternative to coaching everyone the same way. It also has limits: it assumes the cause of a performance gap sits inside the person, and it can turn a passing read on someone's motivation into a lasting label. This article covers how the matrix works, how to use it and what it misses, drawing on recent research and on our [leadership coaching](https://www.ppsinternational.net/coaching) work at PPS International Limited. Talent development leaders can go straight to the section on building the skill across a manager population.

## What is the skill-will matrix?

The skill-will matrix is a two-by-two grid. One axis shows skill: the knowledge, experience and ability a person brings to a particular task. The other shows will: the person's motivation, confidence and commitment to that task. Placing someone on both axes suggests one of four coaching approaches.

![Skill-will matrix diagram. Skill increases from left to right and will increases from bottom to top. Low skill and low will: direct. Low skill and high will: guide. High skill and low will: excite. High skill and high will: delegate.](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hs-fs/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/skill-will-matrix-quadrants.png?width=1200&height=900&name=skill-will-matrix-quadrants.png)

*The skill-will matrix: a coaching approach for each combination of skill and will on a specific task \[1\].*

Max Landsberg described the matrix in his classic coaching book, *The Tao of Coaching*, first published in 1996 \[1\]. It also appears as the will-skill matrix or the skill/will matrix, and the ideas are the same.

The matrix works best when a manager places a person on one task at a time. The same sales representative may be skilled and motivated in client meetings and new to building the quarterly forecast, which places them in two different quadrants for two parts of one role.

## Skill vs will: what each axis measures

Skill and will describe different things, and mixing them up can lead a manager to coach the wrong problem. Skill is whether the person can do the task to the standard. Will is whether they want to and believe they can. Here is how the two axes compare:

| Axis | What Is Included | Evidence to Look For | Common Misreads |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Skill | Knowledge, technical ability, experience with this task and judgment in new situations | Results on similar work, direct observation, work samples and the person's own account of how they approach the task | A skill gap read as low effort; experience in one task assumed to carry over to another |
| Will | Motivation, confidence and commitment to this task, and how much the person values it | What the person says about the task, the initiative they show and how they respond to setbacks | Low confidence, unclear expectations or an overloaded schedule read as a lack of motivation |

Will is also more than a single dial. A meta-analysis of 124 samples found that the kind of motivation matters as well as the amount. Employees who valued the purpose of their work tended to perform better and to help colleagues more, while motivation driven mainly by outside pressure had limited links with behavior and carried well-being costs \[2\]. Connecting a task to something the person values, such as a customer outcome or a skill they want to grow, is one promising way to build will.

## The four quadrants and how to coach each

Each quadrant suggests a different coaching approach. Here is a summary, followed by notes on each:

| Quadrant | Common Signs | Coaching Approach | What the Manager Can Do |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Low skill, low will | New to the task and unsure of its value or of their ability to succeed | Direct | Explain why the task matters, set clear expectations, break the work into small steps and check in often |
| Low skill, high will | Eager to take the task on and still learning how to do it well | Guide | Demonstrate, explain the reasoning, give practice with feedback and loosen supervision as skill grows |
| High skill, low will | Capable of the task and disengaged, frustrated or unsure of its purpose | Excite | Explore the reasons for low willingness, connect the task to the person's goals, recognize contributions and remove obstacles |
| High skill, high will | Capable, committed and often ready for more responsibility | Delegate | Agree on outcomes and check-in points, give authority to decide and offer stretch assignments |

- **Direct when skill and will are both low.** Start with why the task matters, then give clear instructions and frequent check-ins. Early wins can build confidence, and willingness often grows with them.
- **Guide when will is high and skill is still developing.** Demonstrate the task, explain the reasoning behind each step and give real work with feedback. Our [*Masterful Coaching*](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/programs/masterful-coaching) program addresses this situation, in which employees are willing to do a job and still need support to complete it.
- **Excite when skill is high and will is low.** Start with a conversation about the reason for the drop. A capable person may be bored or overloaded, unclear about priorities or frustrated by an obstacle. Encouragement can help: in one field experiment, a brief training that helped leaders encourage, reassure and value employees' efforts raised employee satisfaction and engagement in a later meeting \[3\]. The effect on team performance was not significant, which suggests pairing encouragement with removing whatever caused the drop.
- **Delegate when skill and will are both high.** Agree on the outcome, the timing and how progress will be shared, then give the person room to decide how to get there. Our article on [performance conversations](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/5-conversations-top-performing-managers-have-mastered) describes how to set the expectations and agreements that make delegation work.

People move between quadrants. A strong performer who takes on a new responsibility may move from delegate to guide for that task, and a disengaged expert may return to delegate once an obstacle is removed.

## How to use the skill-will matrix

Here are the steps we recommend when using the skill-will matrix with an employee:

1. **Choose the task.** Pick one task or responsibility that matters now, such as running the weekly client call. A specific task keeps the conversation concrete and fair.
2. **Gather evidence of skill.** Look at results on similar work, observe the task when possible and ask the person how they approach it. Self-ratings can be generous or harsh, so compare them with results; our article on [helping employees see their performance realistically](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/helping-employees-have-a-realistic-view-of-their-performance) covers that conversation.
3. **Ask about will.** Willingness is easier to understand through conversation than through observation. Questions such as these can help: 
     - "How do you feel about taking this on?"
     - "How confident are you that you can do it well?"
     - "What would make this task more worthwhile for you?"
     - "What is getting in the way right now?"
4. **Agree on the placement together.** Share the model openly and compare both views of where the person sits. A placement the employee helped decide may lead to a more open conversation about support.
5. **Choose the approach and a check-in date.** Agree on the coaching approach, the support the person can expect and a date to review progress together.
6. **Revisit the placement.** Skill and will change over time, for example after training or during a reorganization. Review placements at regular one-on-ones and whenever the task or the person's situation changes.

### Skill-will matrix template

The template below documents one placement per task. Managers can keep it in a shared document as a coaching record the employee can see. Here it is with two examples for the same sales coordinator:

| Task or Responsibility | Skill Evidence | Will Evidence | Quadrant | Coaching Approach | Next Check-In |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Running the weekly client status call | Has run two calls with support; agenda and follow-up notes incomplete | Volunteered for the role; asks for feedback after each call | Low skill, high will | Guide: plan the next two calls together and debrief after each one | After the second call |
| Preparing the monthly sales forecast | Accurate forecasts for the past three quarters | Says the work feels routine; has asked for broader responsibilities | High skill, low will | Excite: discuss the career goal behind the request and add a stretch element, such as presenting the forecast to senior leaders | In one month |

## What the skill-will matrix misses

The skill-will matrix is a useful starting point for coaching decisions, and it has blind spots worth knowing:

- **It assumes the cause sits inside the person.** What looks like low will can be unclear expectations or missing tools and information. It can also be a task that carries no consequence either way. Clarity is a common gap: Gallup reported in 2026 that clarity about what is expected at work showed the largest decline among the items in its U.S. engagement index since 2020, nine points \[4\]. Our guide to [handling employee performance issues](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/guides/matching-common-performance-problems-to-hr-solutions) covers nine causes of performance gaps, and we recommend working through them before choosing a coaching approach.
- **It treats will as one dial.** The reasons behind motivation can matter as much as its level \[2\], so two people who both seem unmotivated may need very different conversations.
- **The manager is part of the picture.** Gallup's research attributes about 70% of the variance in team engagement to the manager \[5\]. A low-will placement may say as much about the relationship or the way the task was assigned as it does about the employee.
- **Labels can become self-reinforcing.** A two-wave study of 313 U.S. employees found that managers' coaching and employees' role clarity and commitment influenced each other over time, and that employees' attitudes influenced the coaching they reported receiving \[6\]. A person placed in the low-will column may get less coaching, which can lower their willingness further. Sharing the placement and revisiting it often helps prevent that cycle, especially since will can change quickly with a new project or a difficult month at home.

## For talent development leaders: building the skill across a manager population

Talent development leaders often wonder how to help managers coach different people differently, and how to know whether that coaching is improving. Here are a few things to consider from the point of view of talent development:

**Recognize and share value to the organization for building coaching skill in managers.** Benefits can include coaching time that goes where it is needed, performance gaps that get attention earlier and capable people who receive more responsibility. In a matched study of 412 employees in New Zealand, those formally coached by their supervisor reported more meaningful work and more citizenship behavior, such as helping colleagues, than similar employees who were not coached. Their turnover intentions and counterproductive behavior did not differ \[7\].

**Look for cues that managers need support with coaching by skill and will.** A few we look for:

- Managers who coach every team member the same way, whatever the task.
- Strong performers who wait for approvals they could handle themselves.
- New managers who either control every detail or step back too far.
- Performance conversations that stall or are handed to HR.
- Engagement survey items on clear expectations and recognition that score low or decline.

**Consider how to build coaching skill at scale.** Teach the skill-will matrix as one tool inside a broader coaching curriculum, together with how to diagnose the cause of a performance gap. Give managers practice on real cases from their own teams, and ask small groups to compare their placements for similar situations so they can identify their own assumptions about will. Provide the template as a job aid in the flow of work, one of the [performance support tools](https://www.ppsinternational.net/performance-support) that help skills transfer to the job. Programs such as [*Manager as Mentor & Coach*](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/programs/manager-as-mentor-coach) and *Masterful Coaching* build these skills, and [group coaching](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/coaching-at-scale-when-group-coaching-makes-development-more-accessible) can support application afterward. Progress can show up in pulse survey items on clear expectations and recognition, in how regularly managers hold coaching conversations and in more work delegated to capable people.

**Be aware of how other organizations build coaching skill in managers.** Here is an example. A global medical device company growing 30% year over year published new core values that required leaders to use active coaching skills, and its newly standardized performance management process asked managers to coach as well. PPS designed learning activities that included a personal assessment based on the organization's values and virtual and instructor-led training with skills practice, tied to the points in the performance management cycle where managers would use the skills. Participants reported 99% overall satisfaction and rated the facilitation 5.0 out of 5.0. The [coaching skills for leaders case study](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/case-studies/coaching-skills-for-leaders-a-case-study) has the detail, and our [new manager training program](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/case-studies/new-manager-development-a-case-study) guide shows where delegation and performance conversations fit in a new manager curriculum.

## Common mistakes when using the skill-will matrix

- **Keeping the placement private.** A placement the employee does not hear about is difficult to test or correct, and it may quietly shape how the manager treats them.
- **Using quadrant labels in performance reviews or talent decisions.** The matrix describes one task at one moment to guide coaching. We recommend keeping it out of employment-related decisions, which need evidence across the whole role.
- **Directing for too long.** Close supervision that made sense for a new task can feel like micromanagement once skill grows, and it can lower the willingness it was meant to build.
- **Coaching everyone in the same style.** Managers may default to the style they know best, whether directing or delegating, whatever the task or the person.

## Frequently asked questions

### What is the skill-will matrix?

The skill-will matrix is a coaching model that places a person on two axes, skill and will (willingness), for a specific task. It suggests a coaching approach for each of its four quadrants: direct, guide, excite and delegate.

### What is the difference between skill and will?

The difference between skill and will is the difference between ability and willingness. Skill is the knowledge, experience and ability a person brings to a task. Will is their motivation, confidence and commitment to it. A person can have one without the other, which is why the matrix rates them separately.

### How do you use the skill-will matrix with an employee?

Use the skill-will matrix with an employee by focusing on one task at a time. Gather evidence of skill, ask about will and agree on the placement together. Then choose a coaching approach and a date to review progress, using the skill-will matrix template above to document each placement.

### How often should a manager revisit the skill-will matrix?

How often to revisit the skill-will matrix depends on how quickly the task and the person are changing. We recommend reviewing placements at regular one-on-ones and after milestones such as the end of a project or a training program. Revisit a placement sooner if the person's situation changes.

### Should employees know where they sit on the skill-will matrix?

We recommend sharing the placement with the employee. Agreeing on it together may make the placement more accurate and gives the employee a chance to correct the manager's view. Keep placements as coaching notes and out of employment-related decisions.

### Is the skill-will matrix the same as a skills matrix?

The skill-will matrix and a skills matrix are different tools. A skills matrix maps the skills a team needs against each person's proficiency, often to plan training or staffing. The skill-will matrix looks at one person's skill and will for one task to decide how to coach them.

## How to start coaching with the skill-will matrix

Start with one task for each person on a team. Place each person on the matrix for that task, discuss the placement with them and agree on one coaching step and a date to check in. Our [leadership coaching services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/coaching) page describes how PPS supports managers and leaders, and our guide to [employee performance issues](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/guides/matching-common-performance-problems-to-hr-solutions) and the [*Manager as Mentor & Coach*](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/programs/manager-as-mentor-coach) program are practical next resources.

Contact us if your managers coach everyone the same way and you want help building the coaching skills to adapt to the person and the task.

[Start a conversation about coaching skills for managers](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contact)

## References

1. Landsberg, M. (1996). The Tao of Coaching. HarperCollins.
2. Van den Broeck, A., Howard, J. L., Van Vaerenbergh, Y., Leroy, H. and Gagné, M. (2021). Beyond intrinsic and extrinsic motivation: A meta-analysis on self-determination theory's multidimensional conceptualization of work motivation. Organizational Psychology Review, 11(3), 240-273. https://doi.org/10.1177/20413866211006173
3. Haeckl, S. and Rege, M. (2024). Effects of supportive leadership behaviors on employee satisfaction, engagement, and performance: An experimental field investigation. Management Science. Published online April 4, 2024. https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.02170
4. Harter, J. (2026, January 27). U.S. employee engagement declines from 2020 peak. Gallup. https://www.gallup.com/workplace/701486/employee-engagement-declines-2020-peak.aspx
5. Pitonyak, J. and DeSimone, R. (2022, updated 2024). How to engage frontline managers. Gallup. https://www.gallup.com/workplace/395210/engage-frontline-managers.aspx
6. Stone, K., Nimon, K. and Ellinger, A. D. (2024). Examining the predictive validity of a managerial coaching scale: A longitudinal study. Frontiers in Psychology, 15, 1277422. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1277422
7. Mowat, J. W., Haar, J. and Forsyth, D. (2025). The impact of formal workplace coaching on employee outcomes: A matched sample analysis. Human Resource Development International, 29(2), 317-334. https://doi.org/10.1080/13678868.2025.2549541

[Articles](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources?type=articles) [Leadership Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources?topic=leadership-development)

Continue learning

## Recent Resources

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-5638c535fdc78d8968bc.jpg) Article Stay Interviews: The Questions to Ask and How Managers Run Them](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/stay-interviews)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-6aee0114493fb1cfb7c3.jpg) Article Post-Training Survey Questions: 30 Questions and When to Ask Them](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/post-training-survey-questions)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-1939e0beea276e297f28.jpg) Article One-on-One Meeting Questions: 40 Questions Managers Can Ask, by Purpose](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/one-on-one-meeting-questions)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-a6574d51550a99f37e46.jpg) Article Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scale (BARS): Examples and How to Build One](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/behaviorally-anchored-rating-scale)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/raw_assets/public/pps-international/assets/images/resources-hero.png) Article Self-Awareness in Leadership: Why It Matters and How to Build It](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/self-awareness-in-leadership)

### [![](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/pps-international/resources/images/learning-retention-retrieval-practice-featured.jpg) Video Learning Retention: How Retrieval Practice Makes Training Stick](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/videos/learning-retention-retrieval-practice)

## We’re ready for you.

We enjoy discussing possibilities and approaches, so please reach out! Contact PPS International Limited today to explore how we can support your talent development initiatives.

[![PPS International Limited](https://www.ppsinternational.net/hubfs/raw_assets/public/pps-international/assets/images/footer-logo.svg)](https://www.ppsinternational.net/)

PPS International Limited is a trusted learning and development partner empowering teams of all sizes with leadership, communication, influence, sales and professional skills training that drives meaningful business results.

## Stay connected

Get practical learning and development insights from PPS.

## Contact

[+1 864-962-6789](tel:+18649626789)  
[info@PPS-SyNetAmericas.net](mailto:info@PPS-SyNetAmericas.net)

<https://www.facebook.com/PPSinternationalLtd> <https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCeHIccCo8DQh4jCffm5tlVQ> <https://www.linkedin.com/company/pps-international-limited/>

## Expertise

- [Leadership Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/leadership-development)
- [Talent Development](https://www.ppsinternational.net/talent-development)
- [Communication & Influence](https://www.ppsinternational.net/communication-influence)
- [Change & Transition](https://www.ppsinternational.net/change-transition)
- [Sales & HR Effectiveness](https://www.ppsinternational.net/sales-hr-effectiveness)
- [Performance Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/performance-support)
- [Implementation Support](https://www.ppsinternational.net/implementation-support)

## [Resources](https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources)

## About

- [About PPS](https://www.ppsinternational.net/about)
- [Who We Serve](https://www.ppsinternational.net/who-we-serve)

## Solutions

- [Assessments](https://www.ppsinternational.net/assessments)
- [Contract Training & Facilitation](https://www.ppsinternational.net/contract-training-facilitation)
- [Coaching Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/coaching)
- [Instructional Design Services](https://www.ppsinternational.net/instructional-design)
- [Interaction Styles](https://www.ppsinternational.net/interaction-styles)
- [Training Administration](https://www.ppsinternational.net/training-administration)
- [Training Programs](https://www.ppsinternational.net/programs)

## [Shop](https://shop.ppsinternational.net/)

© 2026 PPS International Limited. All rights reserved. [Privacy & Legal](https://www.ppsinternational.net/privacy)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Kelly Fairbairn"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-16T21:57:50Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-16T21:57:50Z",
  "description" : "The skill-will matrix helps managers decide how to coach someone on a task. Learn the four quadrants, use the template and see what the matrix misses.",
  "headline" : "Skill-Will Matrix: How to Use It and What It Misses",
  "image" : [ "https://51770148.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/51770148/pps-international/resources/images/pps-resource-f9d53d631281321ebe08.jpg" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.ppsinternational.net/resources/articles/skill-will-matrix",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.ppsinternational.net/#organization",
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "//51770148.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/51770148/raw_assets/public/pps-international/assets/images/footer-logo.svg"
    },
    "name" : "PPS International Limited"
  }
}
```