How to Conduct Performance Reviews: A Five-Step Meeting Agenda for Managers
Many managers struggle with planning and holding a performance review discussion. This formal feedback time is fraught with concerns over what to say and how to manage the agenda. Regardless of what is included in your organization's performance appraisal or when the process is launched, managers can gain confidence to hold these important conversations by focusing on a proven discussion agenda and framework. The review is one stage of the performance management process; the article covers the whole cycle and ten ways to make it produce results.
In this video, we introduce a simple example and format for holding an appraisal discussion.
In addition to the video example, managers and supervisors can use the appraisal discussion tool to help stay on track with key points.
Download the Appraisal Discussion Agenda Tool (PDF)
A performance review is a formal, documented conversation, usually held once or twice a year, that summarizes performance and often feeds ratings or pay decisions. How to conduct performance reviews well comes down to two things: preparation, and an agenda that makes the meeting a two-way conversation. This page walks through both, using the five steps in the appraisal discussion tool and the demonstration in the video, and our Conducting Performance Reviews program builds the same skills with practice and feedback.
There is room to improve. In a 2024 Gallup study, only about one in five employees said their performance reviews were transparent, were fair or inspired better performance, and 56% formally reviewed their performance goals with their manager once a year or less [1].
How to prepare for a performance review
As the video suggests, much of a good review is decided before the meeting starts. Here are a few things managers can do ahead of time:
- Review the whole period. Gather results, examples and notes from the full review period, so the last few weeks do not stand in for the year.
- Ask for a self-review in advance. The employee's notes give the manager a starting point and show where the two views already agree. In the video, the manager opens the employee's part of the discussion by mentioning the notes the employee provided.
- Check for surprises. Anything significant should already have come up in earlier conversations. When it has, the review formalizes what both people know; our article on the five performance conversations covers the conversations that come before it.
- Plan the time and the place. Most review meetings run somewhere between 30 and 45 minutes, depending on how much there is to cover. Choose a private setting and protect the time from interruptions.
- Anticipate reactions. Identify the points the employee may disagree with and the examples that support them, and decide how you will respond if the conversation becomes difficult. Our guide on difficult conversations at work covers handling reactions in more detail.
- Keep pay separate where you can. Gallup recommends holding pay and promotion discussions separately from performance reviews, so the review can focus on performance and development [1].
A five-step agenda for the performance review meeting
The appraisal discussion tool organizes the meeting into five steps (open and preview, self-feedback, your observations, objectives and a future-focused close). Here is what each step involves, with examples from the demonstration in the video:
- Open the meeting and preview the discussion. Thank the employee, confirm the time and set out the agenda. In the video, the manager confirms that the next 30 minutes or so still work, then explains the order: the employee's thoughts on the year first, then the manager's feedback, then future goals and follow-up, and asks, "How does that sound to you?"
- Ask the employee for self-feedback. Start with the employee's view so the meeting is two-way from the beginning. Useful questions include "What are some of the things that you felt went particularly well for you this year?" and "Was there anything that you would have changed or liked to do differently?" Reflect back what you hear before moving on.
- Provide your own observations. Ask before sharing ("Why don't I share some of what I noticed? Would that work for you?"), then give specific examples. In the video, the manager credits the employee's up-to-date log of customer requirements with keeping a project on budget, then raises a meeting for a pilot rollout that left out a colleague, describes the extra questions and the second meeting that followed and asks, "Did you see that the same way?" If your organization uses ratings, explain what the rating means and ask for the employee's reaction.
- Review and set new objectives. Ask for the employee's view first ("What are one or two things you see that would be important for your role?"), then add your own priorities, including development. In a 2024 Gallup study, employees who were involved in setting their own goals were twice as likely to have clear expectations [1]. Our guide to the individual development plan template helps turn development goals into a plan.
- End on a future-focused and positive note. Check that the employee is comfortable with what has been agreed, ask whether there is anything you have not discussed that they would want you to know, schedule the next check-in and explain the next steps in the review process. A feedforward conversation is a useful way to keep the focus on what comes next.
The steps are not always linear. An employee may raise a goal while reviewing the year, and the conversation can follow it as long as each step is covered before the meeting ends.
What to say in a performance review, and what to avoid
How the feedback is framed makes a difference. Specific observations about the work tend to land better than general judgments about the person. Here are a few contrasts:
| Phrasing That Tends to Backfire | Phrasing That Keeps the Review on Track |
|---|---|
| "You're not a team player." | "When the pilot rollout meeting went ahead without Chris, his team came to me with questions and you needed a second meeting." |
| "You always follow up late." | "On the last two client decisions, the follow-up came a week after we agreed. What got in the way?" |
| "Everyone thinks you did a great job." | "Keeping the requirements log current made it easy to see what had been agreed, and it helped keep the project on budget." |
| "Here is your rating. Any questions?" | "Your rating this year is exceeds expectations, and here is what that means. How does that sound to you?" |
| "Don't worry about it." | "Tell me more about what's behind that." |
Questions to ask in a performance review
Open questions keep the employee talking and the meeting two-way. Here are a few for each part of the agenda:
- What are you most pleased with from this review period?
- What would you do differently if you were starting the year again?
- Which of your goals felt most and least in your control?
- Did you see that the same way?
- What support would help you most in the next period?
- What are one or two things you see that would be important for your role next year?
- Is there anything we have not discussed that you think would be important for me to know?
Our article on employee self-evaluation has more questions that help employees analyze their own results.
When the review does not go smoothly
The video demonstrates what its narrator calls a "smooth sailing" conversation, the kind most reviews are. Sometimes a review becomes "rough sailing," when the employee has concerns or disagrees. A few practices help:
- Listen first. Let the employee finish, and summarize what you heard before responding.
- Return to the examples. Specific, observable examples are easier to discuss than general judgments.
- Separate intent from impact. In the video, the employee explains why a colleague was left out of a meeting; the manager acknowledges that it was not intentional and still discusses the effect.
- Pause if you need to. If the conversation stalls, agree on a time to continue once both people have had a chance to reflect.
Participation matters to how employees receive their reviews: a classic meta-analysis found that employees who participated in their appraisals reported more favorable reactions to them, including satisfaction and perceived fairness [2]. When a review surfaces a performance problem that needs its own plan, our guide on employee performance issues helps identify the cause before deciding what to do.
After the review
Document what was agreed while it is fresh and share a summary with the employee. Follow up within a few weeks on the new objectives, and keep the regular check-ins going; in the video, the manager and employee meet at least monthly, which is why there are no surprises at the review. Gallup found that employees who have quarterly progress checks are 90% more likely to be engaged [1].
For talent development and HR leaders
Talent development and HR leaders often wonder how to make reviews more useful across a whole manager population. Here are a few things to consider:
- Give managers a common agenda. A one-page tool such as the appraisal discussion agenda helps managers run consistent, two-way meetings.
- Build the skill with practice. Review skills improve with practice and feedback, such as demonstrations and paired practice, more than with a walkthrough of the form.
- Align the form with the conversation. Forms and systems that follow the same order as the meeting make the agenda easier to use.
- Look at what the reviews produce. The distribution of ratings, the share of employees with development goals and complaints about surprises show where managers need support. Our article on the performance management system describes the measures.
Common mistakes
- Saving feedback for the review. Surprises at the review undermine trust in the process. Share observations as they happen during the year.
- Relying on the last few weeks. Recent events can crowd out the rest of the period. Keep notes throughout the year.
- Running a one-way meeting. A manager who talks for most of the meeting learns little. Start with the employee's view.
- Letting the rating take over. A debate about the rating can leave no time for objectives and development. Explain the rating, listen and move on to what comes next.
- Skipping the follow-up. Objectives that are not revisited tend to be forgotten. Schedule the next check-in before the meeting ends.
Frequently asked questions
How do you conduct a performance review?
To conduct a performance review, prepare by reviewing the whole period and asking for a self-review, then follow a five-step agenda: open and preview the discussion, ask for the employee's self-feedback, share your observations, set new objectives and close on a future-focused note. Document what was agreed and follow up within a few weeks.
How long should a performance review meeting be?
A performance review meeting typically runs somewhere between 30 and 45 minutes, depending on how much there is to cover. Plan the time in advance and protect it from interruptions.
What should a manager say in a performance review?
A manager should open by previewing the agenda, ask for the employee's view before sharing their own and describe specific, observable examples of results and behaviors. Questions such as "Did you see that the same way?" keep the conversation two-way.
Should employees complete a self-review?
Employees benefit from completing a self-review before the meeting, and managers benefit from reading it. It gives the conversation a starting point and shows where the two views already agree.
How often should performance reviews happen?
Formal performance reviews usually happen once or twice a year. Regular check-ins in between, such as a monthly touch base or a quarterly progress check, keep the formal review free of surprises.
What is a performance appraisal meeting?
A performance appraisal meeting is the formal discussion between a manager and an employee about performance over a review period, usually including feedback, a rating where the organization uses one and objectives for the next period. It is one stage of the wider performance management process.
Where to start
Before your next review, download the appraisal discussion tool above, ask the employee for a self-review and plan the opening in a few sentences. Our Giving Feedback reference guide can be a useful refresher before the meeting. For managers across an organization, our performance review training builds the skills to plan and hold reviews that engage the employee and reduce defensiveness.
Contact us if you want help building review skills across your managers, from planning the conversation to handling the employee's reaction.
Start a conversation about performance review training
References
- Wigert, B. and Barrett, H. (2024, May 6). 2% of CHROs think their performance management system works. Gallup. https://www.gallup.com/workplace/644717/chros-think-performance-management-system-works.aspx
- Cawley, B. D., Keeping, L. M. and Levy, P. E. (1998). Participation in the performance appraisal process and employee reactions: A meta-analytic review of field investigations. Journal of Applied Psychology, 83(4), 615-633. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.83.4.615