Hiring Process Steps: How to Build a Strategic Staffing Process

A magnifying glass beside three wooden figures, one painted red and standing out from the others.

Strategic staffing is the process used to improve the likelihood of filling positions with the most successful candidates. By creating a few specific components for each role, hiring managers and their recruiting and HR teams can be aligned on searching for and hiring the best person for the role. The more aligned the process, the better the outcome. In this four-minute video, we overview the components of a strategic staffing process, including example costs for creating these tools for a common individual contributor role.

Hiring well is the first phase; our employee onboarding process guide covers what happens from selection through the first year, and our talent management metrics article lists the measures for the staffing process that show whether it is working.

Most organizations follow the same basic hiring process steps, from defining the role through interviewing to bringing the new hire on board. A strategic staffing process keeps those steps and adds a few role-specific tools that hold every step to the same definition of success. The first and most important of those tools is a success profile, and the others are built from it. This page describes each step, what strategic staffing adds to it and how much of the process to build for a given role. It draws on the HR effectiveness work PPS International Limited does with talent acquisition and HR teams.

Hiring process steps, and what strategic staffing adds to each

Here are the steps most employers follow and the strategic staffing component that supports each one:

Hiring StepWhat HappensWhat Strategic Staffing Adds
Identify the needA vacancy or a new role is approvedA decision about whether the role is a key role that warrants the full process
Define the roleA job description lists duties and requirementsA success profile that describes the behaviors, skills, knowledge and competencies that predict success in the role
Agree on how candidates will be judgedOften skipped, or left to each interviewerA decision matrix with the must-haves and the ranked desirables from the success profile
Attract candidatesA job posting goes up and recruiters searchA recruiting plan with position write-ups, referral messages and a sourcing list
Screen applicantsRésumés are reviewed against the postingScreening against the must-haves in the decision matrix
AssessSometimes skills tests or reference checksOne or two assessments selected to match the success profile
InterviewInterviewers ask their own questionsAn interview plan with an agenda, behavior-based questions and response descriptors, used by trained interviewers
Decide and make an offerThe team compares impressionsA comparison of every candidate against the same decision matrix, with documentation of the decision
OnboardThe new hire startsA handoff of the success profile and the assessment results, so onboarding starts from what the selection process learned

The steps are not always linear. Recruiting and screening often overlap, and some organizations assess after the first interview. What matters is that every step draws on the same success profile.

Start with the roles that matter most

Strategic staffing takes effort to set up, so it makes sense to begin with the roles where a hiring mistake costs the most or where the organization hires often. Common starting points include customer-facing and sales roles, first-line leader roles and roles that are difficult to fill. Once the tools exist for a role, each new search reuses them, so the effort can pay back across every hire into that role.

Build the success profile first

A success profile is the behavioral description of the skills, knowledge, abilities and competencies that predict success in a given role. It is typically built by profiling the people currently in the role, both those who are successful and those who are not, and by benchmarking similar roles in similar industries or organizations. Our article on competency models describes the research tradition behind this kind of profile.

A job description lists what the role does, while a success profile describes what successful people in the role do, which is what the rest of the hiring process needs to look for. Here are a few guidelines that help in building one:

  • Involve the people who do the work. Interviews or focus groups with successful incumbents and their managers surface the behaviors that matter in practice.
  • Describe behaviors that can be observed. "Builds rapport with new customers within the first meeting" can be assessed in an interview; "good people skills" cannot.
  • Include how the person learns. When PPS supports clients in building success profiles, we often suggest a behavior such as "keeps up with industry and role trends" or "participates in group and self-paced learning," so that learning built into the role is part of recruiting, onboarding and managing.
  • Keep it to the few things that predict success. A profile that lists everything gives interviewers no way to tell what matters most.

The same profile can serve several purposes. In a sales team enablement case study, the role definition (a competency model or success profile) fed the selection tools, a recruiting profile and a selection interviewing guide, as well as the baseline assessment and the training that followed.

Create a decision matrix

A decision matrix is a predefined method for comparing candidates against the success profile. It includes two parts: the things a candidate must have to be placed in the role, and the things that are desirable. Desirables are typically ranked on a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 the most important. In the role described in the video, the items that ranked highest in the success profile were customer service and fit with the current team.

Agreeing on the matrix before the first interview helps the hiring team evaluate all candidates against the same criteria. It also makes the decision more objective, documents how the decision was made and gives the team a way to validate it afterward.

Write the recruiting plan

A recruiting plan outlines the likely avenues for attracting candidates and the tools to use in recruiting. It can include:

  • Position write-ups for advertising, written to catch the attention of people likely to succeed in the role.
  • Sample messages that employees can send when referring people in their networks.
  • A sourcing list: the professional organizations candidates may belong to, the organizations they may work for now and the events and communities where they gather.

Because the write-ups come from the success profile, they describe what the role needs, which can help candidates judge their own fit before they apply.

Choose one or two assessments

Assessments can improve the quality of hiring decisions when they measure what the success profile says matters. We recommend choosing one or two that cover the profile from different angles. In our sales assessment center case study, the assessments were developed to align to the client's success profile while fitting the instruments already in place and the project's timing and budget.

For selection, confirm that each instrument is validated for selection purposes and that it ties to success in the role without cultural or other biases. Most development instruments are not built for hiring decisions; 360s, for example, measure perceptions and are not appropriate for employment-related decisions. Our employee assessment tools page lists what PPS offers, and our guide to choosing assessment tools explains which fits which purpose.

Plan the interview and prepare the interviewers

An interview plan is a specific agenda for holding the interview. It includes how to open the interview, behavior-based questions with specific phrases to use and response descriptors that help interviewers judge whether an answer fits the success profile. A 2022 review of selection research found structured interviews to be the top-ranked selection procedure for predicting job performance [1].

Interviewers need practice to use the plan well. Hiring managers benefit from building a few skills:

  • Planning a time-efficient interview.
  • Using behavior-based questions that uncover specific examples.
  • Recognizing illegal and inappropriate questions.
  • Evaluating all candidates against the same criteria.

Our Hiring the Best program builds those skills and can be tailored to include a company's own hiring practices and tools.

Hand off to onboarding

The selection process learns a great deal about a new hire, and some of it can be lost if onboarding starts from scratch. In the identification phase of our onboarding guide, hiring activities already present the organizational context, the departmental functions and the scope and authority of the role. Sharing the success profile and the assessment results with the new hire's manager gives onboarding and early development a starting point.

How to tell whether the process is working

Our talent management metrics article lists staffing metrics for a strategic staffing process, such as:

  • Reduced time to fill open positions.
  • Improved quality of candidates.
  • Reduced cost to hire.
  • Improved length of tenure.
  • Improved productivity in the first 90 days of employment.

We recommend choosing two or three of these before the process starts and tracking them for the roles that use it, so the results can be compared with hires made before the process was in place.

How much of the process to build

The success profile is necessary in order to design the decision matrix, create the recruiting plan, create the interview plan and select assessments. Beyond that, the scope can fit the role. Some clients choose to build all of the components, and others create the success profile and one or two of the other elements, often the decision matrix and the interview plan. The investment depends on how many roles are profiled, how much data already exists about the people in them and how many interviewers need to be prepared.

Common mistakes

  • Starting from the last job posting. A posting copied forward describes the previous search. Build the success profile from the people who succeed in the role today.
  • Agreeing on criteria after the interviews. When the team decides what matters after meeting the candidates, the decision tends to follow first impressions. Agree on the decision matrix first.
  • Letting each interviewer ask their own questions. Candidates then answer different questions and cannot be compared. Use one interview plan for everyone who interviews for the role.
  • Using development assessments for selection. An instrument built for development may not be validated for hiring. Confirm the instrument is appropriate for selection before using it.
  • Stopping at the offer. What the process learned about the new hire can shape onboarding. Hand the success profile and results to the hiring manager.

Frequently asked questions

What are the steps in the hiring process?

The steps in the hiring process usually run from defining the role and attracting candidates, through assessing and interviewing them, to selecting one and onboarding the new hire; the table above lists nine steps. A strategic staffing process adds role-specific tools to each step, starting with a success profile.

What is strategic staffing?

Strategic staffing is the process used to improve the likelihood of filling positions with the most successful candidates. It aligns hiring managers, recruiters and HR on a shared definition of success for each role and on the tools used to find and select people who match it.

What is a success profile?

A success profile is the behavioral description of the skills, knowledge, abilities and competencies that predict success in a given role. It is built by studying the people in the role, both successful and less successful, and by benchmarking similar roles elsewhere.

What is a decision matrix in hiring?

A decision matrix in hiring is a predefined way to compare candidates against the success profile. It separates must-haves from desirables, ranks the desirables by importance and documents how each candidate compares.

Which roles need a strategic staffing process?

Roles that need a strategic staffing process are usually the ones where a poor hire is most costly or where the organization hires often, such as customer-facing, sales and first-line leader roles. Many organizations start with one or two of these roles and extend the process once the tools are working.

How can hiring decisions be more objective?

Hiring decisions can be more objective when the criteria are agreed before the interviews, every candidate answers the same structured questions and the team compares candidates against a decision matrix. Structured interviews were the top-ranked selection procedure in a 2022 review of selection research [1].

Where to start

Pick one role that you hire for often or that matters most to results, and build its success profile with the people who succeed in it. From there, agree on the decision matrix and the interview plan before the next search begins. Our HR effectiveness programs page describes how PPS supports HR and talent acquisition teams, and the Hiring the Best program and our onboarding guide are practical next resources.

Contact us if you want help building success profiles, interview plans and the hiring skills your managers need.

Start a conversation about your hiring process

References

  1. Sackett, P. R., Zhang, C., Berry, C. M. and Lievens, F. (2022). Revisiting meta-analytic estimates of validity in personnel selection: Addressing systematic overcorrection for restriction of range. Journal of Applied Psychology, 107(11), 2040-2068. https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0000994

We’re ready for you.

We enjoy discussing possibilities and approaches, so please reach out! Contact PPS International Limited today to explore how we can support your talent development initiatives.