Coaching Skills for Managers and Leaders: A Case Study and Guide

Two colleagues talk across a small round table in an open office meeting area.

In this case study, we share how one organization built coaching skills for leaders using a blended learning approach including a self-assessment and practice labs.

Coaching skills for managers are the listening, questioning and feedback skills that help employees think through their work, solve problems and develop. This case centered on three of them (reflective listening, thoughtful inquiry and empathy). This page shares the case, then describes the coaching skills managers and leaders need, coaching questions by purpose and how talent development leaders can build these skills across a manager population. The program draws on the coaching services for leaders PPS International Limited provides to clients.

The coaching skills for leaders case study

Situation

As part of a cultural transformation, the Executive and Senior leadership of a global, medical device company with 30% year-over-year growth, published core values for the organization, several which required leaders to use active coaching skills.

To implement the core values and competencies, managers needed to adopt a “coach approach,” including using skills such as reflective listening, thoughtful inquiry, and demonstrating empathy.

Managers also needed to use coaching skills as part of the newly-standardized formal performance management process.

Desired outcomes

  • Recognize the importance of coaching skills to an organization’s capacity and impact.
  • Explore the value of coaching to develop trust-based relationships.
  • Define coaching skills and identify current barriers to coaching.
  • Simplify coaching to a practical activity which happens naturally in interactions across the organization.
  • Recognize the importance of empathy, humility and psychological safety when coaching.

Our solution

PPS designed a series of learning activities including a personal assessment based on organizational values and a series of virtual and instructor-led training events for the participants.

Some organizations follow a program like this with group coaching to support application of the skills.

The design incorporated thought from the International Coaching Federation and utilized certified coaches as faculty.

All materials were branded to the client organization.

Success indicators

  • Participants signaled 99% overall satisfaction and evaluated facilitation 5.0 out of 5.0.
  • Solution aligned to organization’s core values.
  • Solution referenced organization’s performance management cycle including key process areas where skills would be used.
  • Client’s senior leaders provided visible support and sponsorship.
  • Solution used a blended-learning approach with manageable participation timeframes to allow application, in recognition of organizational growth.
  • Examples, language and graphics used in design took a global leadership audience into account.

Products and services used

Download our Coaching Skills for Leaders Case Study

What made the program work

The program addressed several constraints that are common when organizations build coaching skills across a global manager population. Here are the design choices that helped:

  • Values translated into observable skills. The newly published core values described what the organization stood for but not what leaders should do differently. The design translated them into observable coaching skills, practice activities and application points.
  • A shared language before individual scenarios. Managers varied widely in their use of coaching, so the design first established a shared language and a common skill set, then let participants apply it to their own situations.
  • Coaching simplified into everyday behaviors. Leaders were facing several changes at once, so the program simplified coaching into practical, everyday behaviors to reduce the cognitive and operational burden.
  • A personal assessment based on the organization's values. The learning activities included a personal assessment based on the organization's values. An assessment like this can give the practice activities a personal starting point.
  • Ties to the performance management cycle. The program referenced the newly standardized performance management cycle, including the key process areas where coaching skills would be used.
  • Visible senior sponsorship. The client's senior leaders provided visible support and sponsorship throughout.
  • Designed for a global audience. Examples were globally appropriate and easily adjusted depending on delivery location, and materials were highly visual and used simple language.

Our article on overcoming instructional design constraints describes how each of these choices responded to a constraint in this program.

Coaching skills managers need

Coaching has a solid evidence base. A 2023 meta-analysis of 37 randomized controlled trials of workplace and executive coaching found a moderate positive effect across leadership and personal outcomes [1]. Most of those studies involved professional coaches; managers who coach use many of the same skills in shorter conversations as part of everyday work. Here are coaching skills that managers and leaders commonly use:

  • Reflective listening. Restate what the person said, including the feeling behind it, so they know they were heard and can hear their own thinking.
  • Thoughtful inquiry. Ask open questions that help the person think through a situation and arrive at their own options.
  • Empathy. Recognize how the situation looks and feels from the employee's point of view, and say so.
  • Building rapport. Establish a coaching partnership with clear expectations, so the employee knows what coaching conversations are for.
  • Identifying coaching opportunities. Notice moments in everyday work, such as a new task, a setback or a request for help, when a short coaching conversation fits.
  • Describing behavior specifically and objectively. Base observations on what the person did and its effect, so feedback is useful and accurate, whether corrective or reinforcing.
  • Setting developmental goals. Agree with the employee on what they want to improve and how progress will show, then build a development plan that is specific and motivating.
  • Creating psychological safety. Respond to problems and mistakes with curiosity and humility, so employees feel safe raising them.

Coaching questions for managers

Coaching questions tend to work best when they are open and match the purpose of the conversation. Here are examples by purpose:

PurposeExample Questions
Clarify the goal"What would you like to get out of this conversation?" "What would success look like?"
Understand the situation"What have you tried so far?" "What is getting in the way?"
Explore options"What else could you do?" "What would you try if you had more time or support?"
Agree on next steps"What will you do first, and by when?" "What support do you need from me?"
Reflect and learn"What did you learn from this?" "What would you do differently next time?"

When to coach and when to direct

Coaching is not the right approach for every situation. An employee learning a task for the first time often needs clear direction and a demonstration, while an experienced employee facing a new problem often benefits from coaching questions. Many managers adjust their approach to the person's skill and motivation for the specific task. Urgent situations, safety issues and policy matters may call for direction, followed by a coaching conversation once the immediate need has passed.

Coaching also runs through the performance management process. In the case, managers needed coaching skills for the newly standardized performance management process, and our article on the five conversations managers have throughout the performance cycle shows where coaching fits alongside agreements, feedback and development planning.

Common coaching mistakes managers make

Managers who are new to a coach approach often fall into a few patterns. Here are the common ones and what to do instead:

  • Giving advice too quickly. Offering a solution before the employee has described the situation can end the employee's thinking early. Ask two or three questions first, then share your view if it is still needed.
  • Asking leading questions. Questions such as "Don't you think you should call the client?" are advice in another form. Keep questions open, and be ready for answers you did not expect.
  • Coaching only when there is a problem. When coaching happens only after a performance issue, employees may come to see it as a warning sign. Coach on goals, new tasks and successes as well.
  • Doing most of the talking. In a coaching conversation, the employee does most of the thinking aloud. If the manager is talking more than the employee, it may have become a briefing.
  • Skipping the follow-up. A coaching conversation that ends without an agreed next step and a check-in date may not change much. Close each conversation with what the employee will do and when you will talk again.

For talent development leaders: building coaching skills across managers

Talent development leaders often wonder how to build coaching skills across a manager population, especially when managers' use of coaching varies widely. Here are a few things to consider from the point of view of talent development:

  • Recognize and share value to the organization for building coaching skill in managers. Gallup attributes about 70% of the variance in team engagement to the manager [2], and coaching conversations are one of the ways managers exercise that influence.
  • Look for cues that managers need support. Common cues include employees who only receive feedback during their performance review, coaching that is treated as an intervention for performance problems, leaders who spend most of their time directing others and appraisal discussions in which the manager does all the talking.
  • Consider how to build coaching skill at scale. Establish a shared language and skill set, then give managers practice on their own scenarios with feedback from certified coaches. Connect the skills to the performance management cycle, and support application afterward through group coaching for managers.
  • Be aware of how other organizations solve for uneven coaching skills. Many organizations combine a short program with practice labs, a quick reference guide and follow-up coaching, and ask senior leaders to model a coach approach in their own conversations. Our reference cards for leadership conversations are one example of this kind of quick reference.

Measuring a coaching skills program

The case reported participant satisfaction (99% overall) and facilitation ratings (5.0 out of 5.0), along with design indicators such as alignment to the organization's core values and performance management cycle. To see whether coaching skills are used on the job, consider adding:

  • Direct-report pulse items on how often their manager listens, asks questions and supports their development.
  • Coaching items in a 360 or upward feedback survey, used for development and compared before and after the program.
  • Observed practice in skills labs, rated against the shared skill set.
  • The quality of development goals in employees' plans during the performance management cycle.
  • Engagement survey items on development, tracked over time.

Frequently asked questions

What are coaching skills for managers?

Coaching skills for managers are the listening, questioning and feedback skills managers use to help employees think through their work, solve problems and develop. Common examples include reflective listening, thoughtful inquiry, empathy, building rapport and setting developmental goals.

What is a coach approach?

A coach approach is a way of leading in which the manager helps employees find their own answers through listening and questions, while still giving direction when it is needed. In this case, the organization's core values called for leaders to adopt a coach approach.

How do managers learn coaching skills?

Managers tend to learn coaching skills through practice. A program may combine short instruction on a shared skill set with practice labs on real scenarios, then follow up with group coaching while managers apply the skills at work.

How is coaching different from mentoring?

Coaching and mentoring overlap but differ in focus. Coaching helps a person think through a goal or problem, mostly through questions; mentoring shares the mentor's experience and advice to support someone's longer-term growth. Many managers do both, and our article on managing your first meeting as a mentor covers the mentoring side.

What is coaching leadership?

Coaching leadership is a leadership style in which the leader focuses on developing people through questions, feedback and support for their goals. Coaching skills are what make that style work in practice.

How do you measure coaching skills?

Coaching skills can be measured with direct-report pulse surveys, 360 or upward feedback used for development, observed practice and changes in engagement items related to development.

Where to start

Start by describing what coaching should look like in your organization, in terms of the behaviors your values or leadership model call for, and assess where managers are today. Our Masterful Coaching program builds coaching skills for first-line leaders and managers through demonstrations and practice, and Manager as Mentor & Coach covers coaching alongside mentoring, delegation and feedback.

Contact us if you want help defining what coaching looks like in your organization and building those skills across your managers.

Start a conversation about coaching skills for leaders

References

  1. de Haan, E. and Nilsson, V. O. (2023). What can we know about the effectiveness of coaching? A meta-analysis based only on randomized controlled trials. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 22(4), 641–661. https://doi.org/10.5465/amle.2022.0107
  2. Clifton, J. and Harter, J. (2019). It's the Manager. Gallup Press.

We’re ready for you.

We enjoy discussing possibilities and approaches, so please reach out! Contact PPS International Limited today to explore how we can support your talent development initiatives.