Mentor Meetings: How to Run Your First Meeting, With an Agenda and Topics

Being an effective mentor isn’t difficult, but it does take some planning and effort to do it well. Whether you have been asked to be a mentor by an HR Manager, are participating as part of being a sponsor in a professional development program or were approached by someone who wants your advice and input, the first meeting is important to set the stage and ensure a good outcome.

A mentor meeting is a planned conversation in which a mentor shares experience and advice to support someone's longer-term growth. We recommend treating the first one as a chance to learn about each other, agree how you will work together and understand what your mentee hopes to gain. This article covers what to do before, during and after your first mentor meeting, with a sample agenda, mentoring topics and questions for the meetings that follow.

If you arrange mentoring for others, the section “For talent development leaders: preparing mentors across the organization” covers how to build this skill at scale.

What a mentor meeting is

A mentor meeting is a scheduled conversation between a mentor and a mentee about the mentee's goals and development. Coaching and mentoring overlap but differ in focus. Coaching helps a person think through a goal or problem, mostly through questions; mentoring shares the mentor's experience and advice to support someone's longer-term growth. Many managers do both, and our coaching skills case study covers the coaching side.

The quality of the relationship tends to matter as much as having a mentor at all. A 2020 review of workplace mentoring research reported small to moderate effects on mentee and mentor outcomes, with considerable variation from study to study [1], and a 2022 critical review found positive consequences in particular circumstances for particular groups of employees [2]. In a 2025 study of 268 full-time employees, mentorship quality explained the link between what mentors did and employees' self-esteem and well-being [3]. A first meeting cannot guarantee a strong relationship, but it may help to start one.

Sometimes, your organization will have guidelines to help you and your mentee start out on the right track. Other times, you manage the process yourself. When that’s the case, here are some guidelines for managing your first meeting as a mentor:

Before your first mentor meeting

  • Review any published guidelines about the process and expectations for mentoring.
  • Ask those who were involved in pairing you with the mentee (i.e., the mentee’s manager or HR Manager) to share why they thought the match would be beneficial and what they hope comes from the mentoring.
  • Ask for your mentee to provide his/her resume or URL to his/her LinkedIn profile.
  • Share your resume or URL to your LinkedIn profile with your mentee.
  • Review the mentee’s resume or LinkedIn (if it exists) profile in order to gain a better understanding of his/her professional background.

Here are a few more ways to prepare.

  • Reflect on what you can offer. Think about the experiences and relationships from your own career that may be most useful to your mentee.
  • Decide what you are comfortable sharing. Stories about setbacks as well as successes may help your mentee learn from your experience.
  • Prepare a few questions. The section “Questions to ask in a mentor meeting” offers some to start with.
  • Set aside enough time. We suggest about an hour for the first meeting, in a place where you are unlikely to be interrupted.

During your first mentor meeting

  • Share professional background and information on what your position contributes in the organization including current assignments and areas of focus.
  • Discuss and decide how you will work together, including items such as:
    • The best time and method to meet. Set up your first few meetings.
    • The preferred method for staying in touch between meetings, if there is a need.
    • The type of issues and/or situations that may be discussed.
    • Preferences regarding confidentiality.
  • Ask your mentee about goals and areas where he/she wants input, support or resources.

Here is a sample agenda for a one-hour first meeting. Consider adjusting the timing to fit your mentee and any guidelines from your organization.

TimeTopicWhat To Cover
5 minutesWelcomeExplain why you agreed to be a mentor and what you hope the two of you may gain.
10 minutesProfessional backgroundShare your background, your position and your current areas of focus, then invite your mentee to do the same.
15 minutesGoalsAsk your mentee about goals and the areas where input, support or resources would help.
15 minutesHow you will work togetherAgree on the time and method for meeting, how you will stay in touch, the issues you may discuss and confidentiality.
10 minutesA first topicChoose one current situation to discuss, so that the meeting ends with something useful.
5 minutesNext stepsSet up your next few meetings and agree on what each of you will bring.

Some pairs document these points in a short mentoring agreement. Setting objectives may be especially helpful when mentors are unable to attend program orientation events, according to a 2015 study of an 18-month formal mentoring program at a consumer goods organization [4].

After your first mentor meeting

  • Make note of any agreements the two of you made and schedule any follow up.
  • Consider the rapport established and goals discussed during the first meeting and decide if you think you can continue to be an effective mentor. If not, notify those who suggested the pairing.
  • Share some brief feedback with anyone who suggested the pairing (i.e., manager, HR Manager) about how the first meeting went (not necessarily meeting content).

These steps will help you and your mentee have a successful first mentoring meeting. To download a printable checklist of Being an Effective Mentor: Your First Meeting as a Mentor, click here.

Mentoring topics for later meetings

After the first meeting, topics tend to follow your mentee's goals. Here are a few mentoring topics that often come up.

TopicWhat You Might Discuss
Career directionOptions your mentee is weighing, experiences that may help and choices you have faced
Skill buildingA skill to strengthen, where to practice it and how it fits an individual development plan
Understanding the organizationHow decisions get made, who influences them and how to build stakeholder support
Working relationshipsGiving and receiving feedback, working with a manager and holding difficult conversations
Leading othersMoving from doing the work to leading it, delegating and developing others
Visibility and networksBuilding relationships across the organization and presenting ideas to senior leaders
Workload and well-beingPriorities, boundaries and managing pressure

Mentoring is one of many ways to develop. Our guide to development options beyond formal training may give you and your mentee other ideas to discuss.

Questions to ask in a mentor meeting

Good questions help to keep meetings focused on your mentee's goals. Here are a few for each side.

Questions a mentor can ask

  • What would you like to be different six months from now?
  • What are you working on right now that matters most to you?
  • Where would input from me be most useful?
  • What have you tried so far, and what options do you see?
  • What is getting in your way?
  • What is one step you could take before we meet again?

Questions to ask a mentor

  • How did you decide on your career path, and what would you do differently?
  • What skills have mattered most in your career?
  • What do leaders here pay attention to?
  • What mistakes taught you the most?
  • Who else would be helpful for me to get to know?
  • What feedback would help me most right now?

Common mistakes in mentor meetings

Here are a few patterns that tend to get in the way.

  • Giving advice too early. Listening first may help you understand what your mentee needs.
  • Doing most of the talking. Your experience is valuable, and the time belongs to your mentee's goals.
  • Skipping the goals conversation. Without goals, meetings may drift from one update to the next.
  • Leaving confidentiality unspoken. Agree early on what stays between you and what you may share with those who suggested the pairing.
  • Letting meetings lapse. Setting up your first few meetings in advance can help when schedules get full.
  • Staying in a poor match. If you do not think you can be an effective mentor, consider telling those who suggested the pairing.

For talent development leaders: preparing mentors across the organization

Mentoring is one of the ways people learn from others, which makes it part of many development plans. Mentors may also benefit: an earlier meta-analysis, now a classic, found that mentors reported higher job satisfaction and organizational commitment [5]. Because results vary so widely from study to study [1], preparation and follow-up tend to matter.

Here are a few cues that mentors across your organization may need more support.

  • Pairs stop meeting after the first few conversations.
  • Mentors ask what they are supposed to talk about.
  • Mentees report advice that does not connect to their goals.
  • Mentoring depends on a small group of experienced leaders.

Here are a few ways to build mentoring skill at scale.

  • Give every mentor a simple structure. The first meeting checklist and sample agenda in this article can serve as a starting point.
  • Brief mentors and mentees together. Cover the time commitment, confidentiality and who to contact if a match is not working.
  • Ask pairs to set objectives early. Objectives give each pair something to return to, especially when mentors miss an orientation.
  • Build the underlying skills. Our Manager as Mentor & Coach program equips supervisors and managers with skills such as mentoring, coaching and giving feedback.
  • Check in with pairs. Asking whether pairs are meeting and whether goals are moving forward can show where support is needed.

Mentoring also tends to work well as part of a larger program. In a new manager development program for a global, technically focused organization, mentoring and coaching by mid- and senior leaders were structured and monitored as part of the program, as our article on ways to reinforce training describes. In our digital upskilling case study, participants who visibly applied their learning became mentors to those earlier in their digital transformation journey.

Frequently asked questions

What is a mentor meeting?

A mentor meeting is a scheduled conversation in which a mentor and mentee discuss the mentee's goals, experience and next steps.

What should you discuss in a mentor meeting?

In a mentor meeting, you might discuss your mentee's goals, current situations, career direction, skill building and how the organization works. In a first mentor meeting, the focus tends to be on background, goals and how you will work together.

How do you prepare for a mentor meeting?

To prepare for a mentor meeting, review any published guidelines, learn about your mentee's background and plan a few questions. For later meetings, review your notes and any agreements from the last conversation.

How long should a mentor meeting last?

A mentor meeting often lasts 30 to 60 minutes. We suggest allowing about an hour for the first one.

How often should a mentor and mentee meet?

A mentor and mentee often meet about once a month, although the right frequency depends on the mentee's goals, your schedules and any program guidelines.

Who should lead a mentor meeting?

A mentor meeting tends to work best when the mentee brings the topics and the mentor guides the conversation. In the first meeting, the mentor may take more of the lead.

What should a mentor not do?

A mentor should avoid making decisions for the mentee, sharing confidences or using the relationship to evaluate performance. If the match is not working, it may help to notify those who suggested the pairing.

Where to start

Use the printable checklist to prepare for your first meeting, and set up your next few meetings before it ends. If you are preparing mentors across your organization, our Manager as Mentor & Coach program builds these skills in supervisors and managers, and our coaching services page covers other ways we support leaders.

Contact us if you want help preparing mentors across your organization, from the first meeting to the skills that keep the relationship useful.

Start a conversation about mentoring programs

References

  1. Eby, L. T. and Robertson, M. M. (2020). The psychology of workplace mentoring relationships. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 7, 75-100. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-012119-044924
  2. Ivey, G. W. and Dupré, K. E. (2022). Workplace mentorship: A critical review. Journal of Career Development, 49(3), 714-729. https://doi.org/10.1177/0894845320957737
  3. Sloan, D., Mikkelson, A. C. and Hinnenkamp, C. (2025). Does quality matter? An analysis of mentoring functions, mentorship quality and employee outcomes. Journal of Workplace Learning, 37(5-6), 399-415. https://doi.org/10.1108/JWL-12-2024-0274
  4. Matarazzo, K. L. and Finkelstein, L. M. (2015). Formal mentorships: Examining objective-setting, event participation and experience. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 30(6), 675-691. https://doi.org/10.1108/JMP-02-2012-0041
  5. Ghosh, R. and Reio, T. G. (2013). Career benefits associated with mentoring for mentors: A meta-analysis. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 83(1), 106-116. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvb.2013.03.011

We’re ready for you.

We enjoy discussing possibilities and approaches, so please reach out! Contact PPS International Limited today to explore how we can support your talent development initiatives.